Hi stranger! Signing up for MypetMD is easy, free and puts the most relevant content at your fingertips.

Get Instant Access To

  • 24/7 alerts for pet-related recalls

  • Your own library of articles, blogs, and favorite pet names

  • Tools designed to keep your pets happy and healthy

or Connect with Facebook

By joining petMD, you agree to the Privacy Policy.

petMD Blogs

Written by leading veterinarians to provide you with the information you need to care for your pets.

The Daily Vet by petMD

The Daily Vet is a blog featuring veterinarians from all walks of life. Every week they will tackle entertaining, interesting, and sometimes difficult topics in the world of animal medicine – all in the hopes that their unique insights and personal experiences will help you to understand your pets.

Thiamine Deficiency and Excess Vitamin A in Cats

With the standardization of nutrient quantities in commercial food, thiamine deficiency and vitamin A toxicosis are generally uncommon findings in daily veterinary practice. However, the ever increasing popularity of feeding raw diets or all-organ meat diets to cats may increase the incidence of these conditions despite the well-meaning intentions of their owners.

Thiaminase in Fish

Thiamine or vitamin B1 is an essential nutrient for carbohydrate metabolism, especially in nerve tissue. Raw carp and herring are particularly rich in an enzyme called thaiminase that destroys thiamine. Experimental studies in cats fed diets consisting of raw carp or herring have shown that clinical symptoms can occur in as little as 23-40 days. Whitefish, pike, cod, goldfish, shark, flounder, and mullet also contain thiaminase. There are not the same confirmatory experiments with these fish types to determine if they contain sufficient quantities of thiaminase to produce toxicity. Perch, catfish, and butterfish do not contain active thiaminase.

Early symptoms are non-specific and consist of anorexia, weight loss, and decreased activity. Clinical signs of thiamine deficiency are primarily neurological. Dilated pupils, incoordination, weakness, falling, or circling may be early signs. Abnormal neck positions may precede seizures. Total collapse and prostration characterize the terminal stage of deficiency.

Diagnosis of thiamin deficiency is primarily based on feeding history, but increased blood levels of the carbohydrate metabolism products called pyruvate and lactate help confirm the diagnosis.

Supplementation with intravenous or subcutaneous thiamine will reverse the symptoms within days. Oral supplementation can then be initiated for several months. Animals without severe neurological damage can expect a full recovery. Those with neurological damage may have permanent posture or movement abnormalities that prevent normal physical exercise tolerance.

Thiaminase is deactivated by heat, so cooking carp or herring will prevent thiamine deficiency, provided adequate thiamine is included in the diet.

Vitamin A Toxicosis

Vitamin A is a fat soluble vitamin. Unlike the water soluble B-vitamins that are flushed daily into the urine, fat soluble vitamins are stored in large quantities in the liver and other body organs (kidney, heart, etc.). The inclusion of large quantities of organ meats, especially liver, or all-organ meat diets for cats is presently very popular. This significantly increases vitamin A ingestion and can easily result in excesses.

Vitamin A toxicocis affects the cervical or neck spine and front legs causing a syndrome called deforming cervical spondylosis. The cat’s growing and ever remodeling spine and leg bones, when subjected to excessive vitamin A, can develop outgrowths or exostoses on various areas of the vertebrae and long bones of the forelimbs. These symptoms occur over a long time period so the diagnosis is typically not made until much later in the cat’s life.

It is speculated that the repetitive movements of the cat’s normal grooming habits result in micro-injuries to the neck and spine skeleton, making them susceptible to the effects of excessive vitamin A, which explains the anatomical location of the abnormalities.

Pain and impaired mobility account for the symptoms. Initially, anorexia, weight loss, reluctance to exercise, and an unkempt coat may be the only signs. The unkempt coat is presumably a result of inability to groom due to the neck lesions. A “kangaroo” sitting position or exaggerated flexing of the back legs when walking may characterize more advanced disease. Eventually, forelimb lameness and reduced neck mobility become severely debilitating.

Since the symptoms cannot be reversed, treatment for the pain is the primary approach. Alternative treatments like laser therapy, acupressure, acupuncture, etc., may also be helpful but have not been studied exclusively for vitamin A toxicosis. Changing the diet to a more complete and balanced food may prevent further disease but will not reverse existing skeletal changes.

Dr. Ken Tudor

Image: Imageman / via Shutterstock

Comments  3

Leave Comment
  • Too Much of a Good Thing
    12/13/2012 12:14pm

    So, for those who prepare a home diet for Fido or Fluffy, it's not just a matter of assuring all the right stuff is included, one must also assure there isn't too much of some of those good things.

    Very interesting that raw carp and herring negate the positive of Thiamine/Vitamin B1.

  • raw diets
    12/14/2012 01:28am

    I personally don't know anyone that would feed a cat an all-organ or all fish raw diet. I know it's popular with vets to use scare tactics against clients that would like to feed raw, but this is pretty silly. All it requires is not feeding exclusively fish (I've never even heard of an all-fish raw diet), and not feeding all organ meat, again, never heard of that type of diet. A balanced raw diet is still the best "menu" for a cat.

  • More scare tactics *sigh*
    12/31/2012 09:40am

    "The inclusion of large quantities of organ meats, especially liver, or all-organ meat diets for cats is presently very popular."

    Really? Because I've been researching and educating the public on species-appropriate feline diets for several years and at no point have I ever come across anyone recommending all-organ or even high-organ diets. Not once!

    Furthermore, it is very widely known that fish is NOT a healthy part of a feline diet in anything but snack-sized amounts (10% or less), and then only small, short-lived fish such as krill and sardines (for their Omega 3 content) should be fed. Every single website related to raw feeding cats makes this point! (Feline-Nutrition.org, CatCentric.org, CatNutrition.org, LittleBigCat.org, and so on.)

    Deliberately so or not, this piece is less an honest discussion of nutritional deficiencies and more a not-so-subtle attempt to malign the very healthy (but oh-so-scary) practice of feeding our carnivorous little friends the very diet upon which they were built to thrive.

Meet The Vets