Why Are Cats Such Picky Eaters?

Cats can be picky eaters due to their natural instincts surrounding food and eating behaviors, but it’s important to pay attention to changes in your kitty’s desire to eat food. 

Cats who usually have good appetites and suddenly stop eating (or begin eating more) need to be seen by a veterinarian.

Why Cats Are Finicky Eaters

There are several reasons your cat might be a picky eater.

Natural Instincts

Picky eating can be related to how a cat’s wild ancestors hunted and consumed prey.

Wild cats typically subsist on small, frequent meals of smaller mammals caught during dawn and dusk. As such, your cat may prefer to eat multiple small meals throughout the day.

Fresh prey is usually warm when consumed. As such, your cat may also prefer her food warmed up, whether that’s wet food heated to body temperature (about 100 degrees Fahrenheit) or dry food moistened with a bit of warm water.

Cats may even prefer a specific shape of wet food or dry kibble that emulates the feel of fresh prey.

Learned Preference

Kittens learn from their mother which solid foods are safe and preferable. The mother cat’s diet while pregnant can also influence the types of foods her kittens will prefer as they mature.

Because of this, it’s important to introduce young kittens to foods with different flavors, textures, sizes, shapes, and consistencies to help them be more accepting of a variety of foods as adults.

Continue to feed a variety of types of food throughout a cat's life to maintain their willingness to accept new options. This can be helpful if they need to be on a particular diet later in life for health reasons.

Similarly, cats who were eating a particular food during an illness or a time of stress, such as a hospital stay, may avoid that food in the future because of negative associations.

Location

Cats eat best in low-stress environments that meet their need for cleanliness. For example, cats will usually not eat well if:

• Their food is placed near a litter box

• Their bowl is in a high-traffic area of the home

• There are other animals around when they are eating

• Their food is stale, rancid, or in a dirty container

Some cats will even refuse to eat much if their food bowl is near their water bowl or fountain.

Cats may also not eat well after moving to a new home or if their bowl was relocated to a different area.

Medical Issues

Sometimes picky eating can be related to a health issue.

• Cats with dental disease may have mouth pain that prevents them from wanting to pick up food, especially kibble. 

• Cats with kidney disease or other health problems may experience nausea that decreases their appetite. 

• Arthritis pain in older cats may make them less willing to get up to eat or lean over a bowl. 

• Cats with nasal congestion may have a lower desire to eat because they may not smell their food as well, and the aroma of food is important for stimulating appetite.

How To Get a Picky Cat To Eat

If your cat is turning their nose up at their food, trying one of these methods might help them eat better.

Offer Different Flavors

One of the first things you can try if you have a picky cat is changing the flavors of the food they eat. For instance, if your cat has been eating mostly beef, try fish or chicken.

A great option is the Tiki Cat After Dark Variety Pack canned cat food, which comes in five flavors: chicken; chicken and quail egg; chicken and duck; chicken and lamb; and chicken and beef.

Rotating these flavors can keep your cat interested in their meals.

Try Different Textures and Shapes

If your cat eats wet food, they may prefer some textures over others. If they’ve been eating mostly pâté, for example, they may be more interested in stews, morsels, or strips.

If your cat eats dry food, they may prefer different sizes and shapes of kibble, such as round, oblong, triangle, or X-shaped. Purina Cat Chow features different kibble shapes in each bag that may be enticing.

If your cat has been exclusively on dry food, offer some wet food, or vice versa.

Adjust the Temperature

One trick that can help a picky cat is experimenting with the food’s temperature. Some cats may prefer their food warm, while others may prefer room-temperature food or even food chilled in the refrigerator.

You can also add a little warm water to dry kibble to see if that will tempt your kitty to eat.

Add Food Toppers

Cat food toppers like Tiki Cat Broths, combined with wet food or kibble, can also serve as useful tools for enticing picky cats. These broths can be placed on the food either as-is or warmed up to increase the aroma.

Try Interactive Eating

Some cats may be more interested in eating if they are able to practice their instinctive hunting behaviors and work for their food. 

Treat-dispensing toys or puzzle toys can be great ways to feed your cat part of their daily calories while also providing enrichment.

Change Up the Eating Schedule

If your cat has been on a strict eating schedule, such as one morning and one evening meal, and has become picky about her food, it may help to change their routine.

Some cats prefer to eat multiple smaller meals throughout the day instead of larger meals fed several hours apart. By contrast, some cats may do better with timed meals if they are used to free-feeding.

An automatic feeder, like the Casfuy Smart 6-Meal Automatic Feeder, can help when you are out of the house.

Try Stress-Relief Techniques

Stress may also affect your cat’s willingness to eat their meals. Trying a calming pheromone such as Feliway Calming Diffuser or a stress-reducing probiotic powder like Purina Calming Care. These may increase feelings of relaxation and help your cat eat better.

In addition, creating an ideal eating space for your cat can help them feel more comfortable during their meals. This can include placing their food bowl in a quiet area and restricting access from other animals when they’re eating.  

If Your Cat Is Suddenly a Picky Eater

If your cat has suddenly become a picky eater, most of the time there’s a medical reason. This can include kidney disease, gastrointestinal issues, dental disease, arthritis, respiratory infections, and heart disease.

Seek veterinary attention when your cat’s appetite suddenly decreases. Do not allow your cat to go more than 24 hours without eating. 

Cats can develop potentially life-threatening hepatic lipidosis (fatty liver disease) if they don’t eat regularly, so making an urgent veterinary appointment is crucial if you see any changes in your cat’s appetite.