Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
The Daily Vet is a blog featuring veterinarians from all walks of life. Every week they will tackle entertaining, interesting, and sometimes difficult topics in the world of animal medicine – all in the hopes that their unique insights and personal experiences will help you to understand your pets.

 

Should I Keep My Cat Indoors?

PrintPrint

September 28, 2011 / (11) comments

Last week, we talked about avoiding the "hit-by-car" emergency by keeping your dog or cat under control: either on a leash or by keeping them indoors. As I previously mentioned, I got a lot of grief from some feline owners and veterinarians when It's a Cat’s World … You Just Live In It came out. Why? Because I stated my opinion: that cats should be kept indoors.

 

First, there are several medical reasons for why to keep your cats indoors. Let the statistics do the talking: The average outdoor cat lives to two years of age, while the indoor cat lives to a more geriatric age (approximately fifteen to eighteen). So ultimately, it depends on how long you want to have your cat around.

As a veterinarian, I’ve seen too many cats succumb to the "trauma of outdoor living": being mauled by dogs, maimed by cars, shot by BB guns, etc., only to have pet owners who couldn’t afford to have them treated (resulting in euthanasia). Top it off with the fact that you’re also putting your cat more at risk for the following:

  • Increased exposure to outdoor poisons (e.g., a few bites out of your day lilies or licks of antifreeze from your neighbor’s driveway can result in life-threatening acute kidney failure)
  • Increased risk for pet overpopulation (If your cat’s not neutered or spayed yet, please don’t let him or her out!)
  • Contributing to the spread of toxoplasmosis all over your neighborhood
  • Contributing to the killing of migrating song birds

Believe it or not, outdoor cats don’t necessary have more fun, and yes, indoor cats can be just as content living indoors. If you’ve already decided to let your cat outside, just be aware that once cats have tasted the "great outdoors," it’s harder to keep them from crying for it, begging for it, or running out when that screen door opens. For that reason, it’s always the safest approach not even to let your cat experience the great outdoors to begin with.

Also, if you decide to let your cat outside, just be prepared to have him snatched away — permanently. A good-intentioned neighbor may think they have found a sweet cat and decide to keep your cat as their own … right after you paid for the spay/neuter and vaccines! Hence, all the "Lost Cat: Reward!" signs in the ‘hood.

If you decide to keep your cat indoors, keep your cat content by committing to exercising your cat more. It’s the simplest way to add environmental enrichment to your cat’s routine. If you love your cat (yes, I’m trying to use guilt here!), exercise your cat for at least ten minutes, once a week. First, exercising your cat allows him or her to bond to you more (and hopefully, vice versa). Second, it’s a great way to help your cat lose weight and stay trim and healthy. While the majority of cats I see are overweight and sedentary, it’s not their fault — it’s because they lack exercise by their owner. Third, exercise is important because it’s great mental and physical stimulation. Make sure your cat has plenty of cat-safe toys, catnip, cat grass, scratching posts, and laser pointers to chase.

For all you naysayers, don’t get me wrong — if I lived in the perfect environment (at the end of a cul-de-sac with minimal traffic, on a farm away from roads, etc.), I’d consider letting my cat outdoors … so there are some situations where I think it’s OK. However, most of my clients are from an urban environment, where cats and roads don’t mix. If you have a fenced in yard, or can teach your cat to walk on a leash, I think supervised outdoor time is great — provided you’re there to get them out of a bind if necessary (after all, curiosity killed the cat!).

If you do let your cat outdoors, please consult your veterinarian about appropriate vaccine protocols. I normally don’t recommend the FeLV or FIV vaccine, but that’s because the FeLV vaccine isn’t 100 percent effective and has very rare but potentially severe side effects (like a cancer called fibrosarcoma at the site of injection). That said, if you allow your cat to go outdoors, the vaccine is a must (as it is for all the other cats in your household, regardless if they go out or not!).

Finally, if your cat is declawed, please don’t let him go outside. While this seems like common sense to me (as it’s a dog-eat-dog world out there, and sending a declawed cat outdoors is like sending him to war without a gun), I’ve seen lots of pet owners do it. Common sense may not be so common, as I often see bird feeders in the yard also. Want to keep your cat outdoors? You lose the right to use bird feeders!

I’m expecting lots of controversial comments here, as I’ve already gotten a lot of grief for my opinion, but please do share. What do you think?

 

 

Dr. Justine Lee

 

 

Image: Ozerov Alexander / via Shutterstock

 

Subscribe to The Daily Vet
COMMENTS (11)
1
No Grief
by TheOldBroad on 09/28/2011 07:32am

You'll get no grief from me because I agree 100%.

One of my kitties, Stan, was a neighborhood stray - skinny and ALL FOUR DECLAWED. (I'm against declawing, but declawing on all four feet should be a crime.) He's the reason I can't use the front door because he'll fight to get outside. It actually has a hidden advantage: if I need to find him, all I have to do is rattle the door knob and he comes running.

My Owen was an unaltered stray that took up residence in my back yard. He has congenital heart problems (well controlled with medication), but is also FIV positive. FIV shouldn't be a death sentence, but there's no reason he should have it. He should have been fixed and he should have been kept indoors.

Winston (RIP) was literally on the verge of death when he came to my door. It was the middle of winter and he was very cold. Every bone in his body was sticking out and he had every parasite known to catdom. Plus he smelled truly awful as an unaltered male. Who knows if he was dumped or just got lost, but it was obvious he had been on his own for quite awhile.

I don't regret taking any of them in, but I've wished their previous humans had used some common sense and properly cared for them.

2
agree!
by cat147 on 09/28/2011 04:33pm

totally agree with you! in the majority of neighborhoods, it is not safe to let the cats roam free.

3
Right ON Dr. Lee!
by MiamiAngel on 09/28/2011 05:54pm

I absolutely agree! My sister's inlaws had an indoor/outdoor cat but they lived in the country with acres of land and only two neighbors. She lived to 18 years of age.

My five are in a highrise condo and I only let them on my balcony two at a time with me standing right next to them so they don't get any ideas. Just a little fresh air breather in the winter and spring. Summer is too hot.

Using a leash is an excellent idea but make sure there are not too many dogs around.

Sadly one resident's dog did maul and kill one of our managed colony of outdoor cats (MR. Big)who was in bushes and didn't even provoke the dog. And owner had him on a leash but he weighed more than her and she could not control him. Witnesses were horrified and insisted the owner put muzzle on the dog. There was the fear the dog would snap and go after a small child, another dog or a adult! anyone or anything!

Sadly, common sense does not prevail and your posting has all the facts and figures.

4
Totally agree
by mharding01 on 09/30/2011 12:25pm

I often see a sweet white/gray cat in my urban neighborhood. Very friendly to people, walks right up to yo. Someone let it into my building lobby and a neighbor brought him to me, thinking it was mine. Alas, no, and with three already I can't have another. This kitty is very clean and seems healthy so I assume he as a home. If I ever find his "guardians" I will let them have it for letting such a sweet cat outside.

by Dr Justine Lee on 09/30/2011 12:55pm

That's why I don't have much empathy for people with the "Lost Cat" signs - it's a risk they take by letting their cat outside. Most of these friendly, outdoor cats often have homes, and simply having a microchip may save that cat's life. Risk of letting your cat outside - a neighborly neighbor may be adopting it!

5
More of a question
by hangela50@yahoo.com on 09/30/2011 03:49pm

I Agree with your cat should be inside, but my daughter's cat does not. Do you have any advice on how to keep him in? He was a stray that ran in to our house on day and made him self at home. We looked around to see if he had an owner, but our manager said he was left behind and we could have him. He is the best cat, but if he wants out and the door opens, he is GONE! He only does it more every few days and 1 time a month it is REALLY bad. Matting I guess??? We have not gotten him fixed and I do not want him with other cats, but do not know what to do......
Thanks,

by Dr Justine Lee on 09/30/2011 05:36pm

It's absolutely imperative that if you let your cat outdoors at ALL, you must get him neutered. He's going out to look for sweet loving, and it directly results in pet overpopulation.

You can train a cat to love the indoors. Use a spray bottle filled with water when he gets near the door, or something to prevent him from nearing the door. Please give him neutered asap!

by TheOldBroad on 09/30/2011 07:12pm

Oh my! What Dr. Lee said.... PLEASE have the kitty fixed as soon as possible.

Not only should it help with his "escape habit", you don't want him starting to spray inside the house.

When my Winston (RIP) knocked on my door and asked to join the family, he absolutely reeked. An unneutered tom usually isn't very pleasant smelling.

6
More reasons for indoors
by Frankster on 09/30/2011 08:04pm

If you cat is an indoor only cat, you'll know how much they eat and drink and how often. You'll know if they have stopped having bowel movements, have problems urinating, etc.

Indoor/outdoor cats and outdoor only cats don't have that safety net. I've also seen many cats in shelters with gun shot wounds, rubber bands around paws, punctures, and abused in other ways. I saw a cat that hid under the hood of the car and rode over 70 miles near the engine. He was lucky to have survived. He was just a little burned and a lot unnerved. I've also seen white cats with cancerous ears due to sun exposure -- white cats who should absolutely always be kept indoors because of the sun.

7
FIV & FIV vaccine
by Frankster on 09/30/2011 08:09pm

First, whereas the test for FeLV (Feline Leukemia) tests for the virus itself, the test for FIV tests for the antibodies only NOT the virus.

Second, I do not recommend that a cat be given the existing FIV vaccine because the cat will then test positive for FIV antibodies. Many, many shelters routinely kill cats that test positive for FIV antibodies. So, if you are going to vaccine your cat, make sure you have him chipped because the shelter will normally call you first thing. However, if they cannot reach you, after some period of time, they'll test him and he will most likely end up on death row due to testing positive for FIV antibodies.

FIV should not be a death sentence. These cats can live long, healthy, happy lives with proper care just like other cats. For more information, go to www.FIVCatRescue.org

Frankie Kangas, Co-founde, FIV Cat Rescue, Fort Bragg, CA. email: frankie@FIVCatRescue.org

by Dr Justine Lee on 10/01/2011 06:45am

Totally agree. The FELV vaccine is also not 100% protective (your cat will still get FELV, but not as severe disease)... so the safest thing is to always avoid these infectious diseases by keeping your cat indoors!

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.

 


MEET THE VETS

Lorie Huston, DVM is a small animal veterinarian with over 20 years experience...
READ MORE

Patrick Mahaney, VMD is an integrative veterinarian who combines western and eastern perspectives...
READ MORE

Ken Tudor, DVM has a veterinary practice focused exclusively on pet weight loss and management...
READ MORE

Anna O'Brien, DVM is a large animal veterinarian working just outside of Washington, D.C. in Maryland...
READ MORE

Dr. Joanne Intile, DVM, DACVIM is a Cornell trained veterinary oncologist practicing in Maryland…
READ MORE

  • Lifetime Credits:
  • Today's Credits:
Hurry Before All Seats are Taken!
Enroll
Be an A++ Pet Parent! Take fun & free courses to earn badges & certifications. Choose a course»
Subscribe to The Daily Vet

Most Read Daily Vet Articles

Five Common Mistakes Made by Cat Owners
The average cat owner often overlooks some important aspects of their pet’s health...
READ MORE
The Unnecessary Anger of the Pet Food ...
This week Dr. Ken Tudor addresses the anger pet owners feel when discussing pet...
READ MORE
Top Five Holistic Pet Cancer Prevention Tips
May is Pet Cancer Awareness Month. Today Dr. Patrick Mahaney lists his top five tips...
READ MORE
Pet Food Recalls and Safety
It is important to realize that recalls occur as a means of keeping our pet’s safe....
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

The Unnecessary Anger of the Pet Food ...
This week Dr. Ken Tudor addresses the anger pet owners feel when discussing pet...
READ MORE
Top Five Holistic Pet Cancer Prevention Tips
May is Pet Cancer Awareness Month. Today Dr. Patrick Mahaney lists his top five tips...
READ MORE
The Agony of Arthritis – Is Your Cat ...
Since May has been proclaimed Arthritis Awareness Month, it seems a good time to...
READ MORE
All in a Day's Work
There are some comments that can be particularly wearing in the course of a day’s...
READ MORE

PETMD POLL

What do you use to prevent ticks from feeding on your pet?

Spot-on meds
60% (113 votes)
Oral meds
14% (26 votes)
Tick collars
8% (15 votes)
Other
6% (12 votes)
N/A (I do not use tick preventives)
11% (21 votes)
Total votes: 187

Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2013 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved