Pet Food Survey

Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
The Daily Vet is a blog featuring veterinarians from all walks of life. Every week they will tackle entertaining, interesting, and sometimes difficult topics in the world of animal medicine – all in the hopes that their unique insights and personal experiences will help you to understand your pets.

 

For Love of Dog - How Much Would You Pay for Your Dog?

PrintPrint

June 29, 2011 / (22) comments

By now, most of you know JP, my 12-year-old rescue pit bull, cancer survivor extraordinaire. JP is the first dog that I’ve ever owned as a responsible adult. Not only is he the main character in my book It’s a Dog’s Life… but It’s Your Carpet, but he’s been my main squeeze for the past decade plus.
 

JP has been my loyal companion and "Justine-supporter" through many a move, transition, job, residency, and boyfriend. JP is named after Jamaica Plain, an up-and-coming (i.e., ghetto) subdivision of Boston where I used to live. (This is on the infamous "other" side of the tracks, where one needs a pit bull to safely walk down the street.) Since rescuing him from parvovirus, he’s been a fantastic, well behaved, obedient ambassador for the breed.

One year ago today, JP acutely seizured. As an emergency critical care veterinary specialist, I knew instantly what this meant — something horrible: a stroke, a hypertensive event, or a brain tumor. Unfortunately, a few days later, JP was diagnosed with an aggressive brain tumor (a suspected glioma) based on the MRI.

Panic set in. This dog was my main love: above boyfriends, family, and friends. The rational, scientific side of Justine fought with the emotionally charged, "pathologically-attached-to-my-dog" Justine. I frantically called fellow colleagues who specialized in veterinary oncology or neurology to figure out what to do. My options…

Euthanasia - Humanely euthanizing him
Average life span: 0
Cost: $200-$400
Pros: He doesn’t suffer; no seizures or behavioral changes to deal with
Cons: He’s dead, I’m a mess, and I’ve had no time to spend with him

Medical management - Putting him on anti-seizure medications and steroids (to reduce the swelling in his brain)
Average life span: 1-2 months
Cost: $200-$400
Pros: Cheap
Cons: I’m still dealing with bad seizures; I have to deal with side effects from the medication (e.g., excessive thirst, urination and hunger); and I don’t get that much more time with him

Traditional radiation therapy +/- chemotherapy - Putting him under anesthesia once a day for 21 days for radiation therapy to zap his whole brain (including healthy brain tissue)
Average life span: a few months
Cost: A few thou’ ($3-$4,000)
Pros: I can get it done locally in St. Paul, MN
Cons: High risks of anesthesia, low specificity of radiation

Stereotactic radiation therapy (SRT) - Putting him under anesthesia once a day for 1-4 days for a specialized radiation therapy that zaps only his tumor — not his whole brain. Average life span: 4-10 months
Cost: $8000-$10,000
Pros: Cutting edge technology where it’ll maximize a good quality of life; specific localized radiation against evil tumor cells
Cons: High risk of anesthesia; expensive — it costs more than my car; and I’d have to drive cross-country for it (as it’s only offered in a few places in the United States)

Brain surgery - Putting him under anesthesia and having the tumor surgically "debulked" (which is a nice way of saying "melon-scooped" out, as an anonymous veterinary oncologist told me).
Cost: Free, thanks to an NIH grant at University of Minnesota
Pros: Cutting edge research; free; done by board-certified specialists
Cons: High risk of anesthesia; risk of having a mentally-impaired dog post-operatively

 

So what did I do?

I needed to do everything that I could, as long as it didn’t hurt JP or put him through what I deemed to be too much. I wanted my dog — not a mentally impaired dog — and couldn’t handle the risks of JP losing his cognitive function or personality.

So, thanks to a 5-hour energy drink and a mocha, I drove non-stop from St. Paul, MN to Fort Collins, CO to one of the top oncology departments in the world at Colorado State University for stereotactic radiation therapy. Thanks to the support of some excellent counseling staff at Argus Institute (part of Animal Cancer Center’s team), I was able to survive the tumultuous, stressful, one week experience…
 
A few weeks later, once JP was recovered, a friend asked me, "What’s the cost-benefit ratio to you?" In other words, how long would JP have to live before it was worth the financial investment for SRT?? Bluntly, I said that if I got an extra six months with JP, I’d be happy. I needed that time with JP to say goodbye, provided it was a good quality life.

One year later today, I crunched the numbers. Between his MRI, CT, blood work, SRT, medications, pet-sitting and dog walking fees, treats, emergency endoscopy (Damn rawhide!), etc., JP cost me $37/day since his initial seizure one year ago.

And you know what? It was worth it.

While my friends and family were appalled by what I spent on JP, I needed it. (This coming from the girl who is too cheap to splurge on Starbucks mochas more than once a week.) All in all, I’m ecstatic that I had an extra 365 days to spend with JP. My love for that mutt runs deep, and I’m blessed that I was able to afford it.

I’m cognizant that most people aren’t, but where people splurge on cars, plasma screen TVs, and assorted materialistic things, I splurge on pets. (I do drive a 2000 Hyundai, after all). Besides which, $37/day is a hell of a lot cheaper than a daily shrink visit … and JP has provided me a lot of mental health.

JP is on his last leg, and I’m battling the decision to humanely euthanize him as we speak. I’m not even sure if he’ll be alive by the time this blog posts. Regardless, JP would appreciate the dedication in The Daily Vet.

To all those pet owners out there struggling with cancer: Hang in there. Whatever decision you make is the right one.

To JP: Thank you for teaching me more than I could ever learn from a two-legged human — devotion, loyalty, companionship, and most importantly, that success isn’t measured by society, but by the joy of a tail wag.

 

 

 

Dr. Justine Lee

 

 

Pic of the day: JP by Me

JP (the dog) and Justine Lee, a vet and her dog, for the love of dog, dog with cancer, pets with cancer, loss of pet, pet death, losing a pet, caring for dogs with cancer, pit bull mix, woman with dog

 

Subscribe to The Daily Vet
COMMENTS (22)
1
Benji my soulmate.....
by jamie76 on 06/29/2011 05:26am

This post really tugged at my heart. Benji was 9 months old when he broke 2 of his front leg. As my vet mentioned, most people will just opt to put the fella to sleep because surgery and follow ups will costs an amount most would not choose to spend on their pets. I picked Benji from the roadside when he was only 3 weeks old. Though we have learned to live with each other for only 8 months+, i love him more than any soul in this world i dare to say. I will dodge a bullet for him if you ask me. So, whole operation thingy and follow ups, costs me a bomb and an agonizing 3 months of recovery from the whole ordeal. He went for the external skeletal fixation method to put the bones back together. Unfortunately the bones could not be straightly aligned, so now Benji’s 2 front legs are curved, but he has been moving around without much problem for the past 5 years now. But the vet did caution us that Benji may face some problem with mobility and pain in the joints due to the awkward shape of his legs when he grows older. We try to ensure that he stays slim and builds leg muscle to hold his weight. Would love to introduce swimming for him to build the leg muscle, but he absolutely hates water. My conclusion is, no matter how much I have to spend for my furkids in order for them to live a happy and healthy life, or how difficult situations could be, I would do it without a doubt as my furkids have given me a new meaning to life and Benji is a part of me for eternity.

2
Priceless
by My5beagles on 06/29/2011 06:33am

Simply put my pets are priceless. I won't do heroics to extend their life for my benefit but if I can give them a better quality of life I will do it. I wouldn't change a thing I did for Lilly. The seven months I had after the surgery were just plain wonderful. For me there isn't enough money in the world that could make up for that time because I never would have known the "happy dance". And besides I like macaroni and cheese and driving a twelve year old Jeep. I'll never be wealthy but thanks to my dogs I am the richest person in the world. RIP Lilly....JP you are in my prayers.

3
Cost Ratio?
by TheOldBroad on 06/29/2011 07:19am

Luckily I have never had to weigh the cost of a treatment against the possible amount of time I'd get with a critter.

Working with the doctor, we discuss the treatment against the quality of life for the pet. We provided hospice care for a kitty with adenocardinoma. She got 10 good days. We did chemo for lymphocytic lymphoma. He got 2 good years. We provided lots of different things for a kitty with a myriad of problems. She got 2 good years.

I've always told the doctor that I don't want to treat a pet for MY sake; it's always what's best for them.

Yup, I drive a 20 year old car.

4
by Dr. Kenney on 06/29/2011 08:00am

Thanks, Dr. Lee for a great article. This should be helpful to all pet owners because many pet owners will one day face a decision like you did. I always give clients options and explain that every situation is different and often there isn't a right or wrong answer.

Some clients aren't financially prepared for the more expensive options even if they wanted to take advantage of them. Pet insurance can certainly help in this instance. Some pet owners don't have the kind of bond with their pet that you did with JP or don't have the mindset of doing anything that's possible just to prolong their time with their pet for just a few months. Yes, there are pet owner who consider it worth spending thousands of dollars just to have 6 more months of quality time with their pet. And yes, some of their friends or family members may think they're crazy. But again, it's not right or wrong - it's just their decision to make.

5
by BB42 on 06/29/2011 08:28am

Dr. Lee,

Only those of us lucky enough know the love!

Thanks for sharing

6
To have loved and lost
by EmoFish91 on 06/29/2011 08:51am

My heart goes out to you and JP. We lost our Akita, Sasha, over a year ago, and some days it still hurts. She had falled and herniated her C5 and C6 disks, and we woke up one morning to find her laying in the yard crying because she couldn't get up. We were referred to a neurologist, and were presented with humane euthanasia, steroid treatment, or a risky surgery that only had a 50% chance that she would ever walk again. At 9 years old, we decided to take her home and do the steroid treatment. It was a few weeks before she finally walked again, and we too had another wonderful year with your baby. Just before we put her down, our goofball Abby came to us. Sasha smacked Abby around a good few times, before Abby got the idea that Sasha was top dog as well as a cuddle buddy. She decided it was time for her to go about 2 weeks later, and we didn't regret our decisions for a single moment. I hope JP's passing is as peaceful as anyone could ever wish, and that you find comfort in unexpected places.

7
Owning a dog costs $20K
by bredfreak on 06/29/2011 09:17am

The reality of the situation is that owning ANY dog costs about $20,000 over the life of the pet. If anyone has a family member or friend who questions what they are spending on a pet, have them look at this calculator. It does not matter what breed you have, it will cost $20K so spending several thousand dollars on procedures as you describe in this article should not seem too crazy.

Dont believe it? http://www.breedfreak.com/breedfreak-calculator/

by theflhowes on 06/29/2011 09:48am

I just did the calculator that you linked to. My total for 3 dogs was under $2 thousand combined..... I am not sure where you are getting $20k from. And yes, they all get yearly exams, vaccines every 3 years, heartworm and flea prevent. I buy wholesale for my supplies which saves a lot. All 3 of mine are working farm dogs/livestock guardian dogs and all were adopted from a shelter.

8
$7,000 for 18 months
by msodos on 06/29/2011 10:55am

While my dog did not have cancer, she had complete kidney failure! An we were told we had 2 choices; euthanize or try to keep her infused with liquids! We chose to infuse her with 500 ml of lactated ringer twice a day. This we did for 18 months. When the dog had lost enough weight that the needle was obviously hurting, I called the vet and said "no more". The vet told me that with nokidney function she would one day go to sleep and not wake up.
Wrong! She finally had to be euthanized.

Think back on the 18 months and the expense; all I have to say is that I would do it again in a heartbeat!

9
If we could afford it...
by amirek on 06/29/2011 11:32am

I'm happy that you were able to afford such a procedure for your dog. The sad reality is that most of us could not. When it comes down to treatment for your dog or feeding your family, the choice is sad, not easy, but clear-cut.

Commentaries like this one are good because they do offer us some idea of what our options are if one of our pets becomes seriously ill. However, it also imparts a sense of guilt on those who just don't have the means to provide such wonderful treatment for our beloved companions.

Would that we could all afford to spend $8,000 to $10,000 on our fur-kids, despite the fact that it would only impart a few months of additional time with them on this earth...

10
by Dr Justine Lee on 06/29/2011 11:48am

Thanks for all the great comments and well-wishes. It's a tough decision, and as a veterinarian, I always have to work with the pet owner based on their emotional, mental, and financial decision... which is a fact of life. I've very fortunate in that I was able to afford advanced care, but I'm also a really frugal saver for emergencies.

I do think it's important that pet owners start savings accounts for their dog, particularly as they age. Saving $1-2 dollars a day into a separate savings account is a great way to start.

I don't like seeing pet owners put themselves at debt, and would rather they prioritize feeding their two-legged kids over the expense of their four-legged. That said, I've had to euthanize many a pet in my career because the pet owner claimed financial constraints, yet they always had an iPhone and drove off in a nicer car than mine.

When in doubt, find a veterinarian who works with you and your budget - as you can see from JP's situation, there are definitely lots of options, and our goal is always to preserve quality of life in the end...

11
My rescue pitbull
by VetsRock on 06/29/2011 02:30pm

Your post really hit home for me. I rescued my pit bull from a neighbor when he was 4 months old. He was malnourished and even though they'd had him for over 2 months they had not even given him a name.

I really bonded to him and was devistated when he was diagnosed with severe bilateral hip dysplasia at 10 months of age and bilateral luxating patellas at 14 months. With the level of deterioration if we didn't intervene he was going to be completely crippled with arthritis in the next few years.

So we got his knees fixed first hoping that it would help and it did for a couple years - but then he started deteriorating again so just a few months ago he had one of his hips replaced. Total cost for these procedures was over $8000.

Some members of my family don't understand why I would spend so much on "just a dog" especially when I have other dogs. But none of my dogs are "just dogs" to me.

I am lucky that I can afford this treatment...and while it hurts that members of my family don't understand their approval didn't factor into my decision. They spend their money on things I don't understand - but it's their money... and my money is mine to spend as I choose.

My dog can walk over a mile now without being in pain for days afterward...before the hip replacement he couldn't even make it around the block. YES it was worth it.

I am so sorry that you are coming to the end of your journey with JP, but I am glad that you have had this extra time to spend with him before you let him go.

12
by Dr. Kenney on 06/29/2011 05:46pm

"...and while it hurts that members of my family don't understand their approval didn't factor into my decision. They spend their money on things I don't understand - but it's their money... and my money is mine to spend as I choose."

VetsRock,

That is the best explanation (answer) for this situation I have ever seen!

13
price of a pet
by BarbaraA on 06/29/2011 05:54pm

Dr. Lee,

I hope that your days with JP are good ones and trust that when the time has come you will know best.

I have extended a couple of mine to quality life I would never trade for money. And it was only because I could do so and in the best interest of my pet.

Dottie, and old tough gal got 7+ months with glaucoma treated. Her daughter Pearl, treated with IVDD surgery at 8 yrs. is soon to be 14 yrs.

But my beloved Pocket, that sat in a cage, all the while we asked for euthanasia? Not because we loved her less, but because it was time. And for her to be inhumanely killed in my arms---well you might guess how that feels. Something you can never recover from.

Pocket's Story from NH

14
You and JP
by TheOldBroad on 06/29/2011 07:57pm

I've been thinking about you and JP all day. Hope you're doing OK.

by Dr Justine Lee on 06/29/2011 09:33pm

Thanks so much @TheOldBroad. He's hanging in there but will likely euthanize him this weekend... :(

by TheOldBroad on 06/30/2011 06:25am

I'm so sorry, Dr. Lee. Please take comfort in knowing he has had a great life with you. Just think what it would have been had you not rescued him.

JP knows he is loved and he loves you. Sometimes loving them and doing what is best is the hardest thing to do.

15
no easy answers
by rockjdog on 07/01/2011 09:28am

Hey Dr Lee,

I am so sorry to hear that it is JP's time. My wishes and prayers are with you.

I think letting go of a loved family member is the hardest thing one can ever do. I found it helps at the vets office (when the time has come) if I tell my pet what she or he meant to me, if possible I have friends that know my pet give me their words too.

I always have a hard time letting go. There was one dog I had that meant the world to me and I had him cremated but i did not take his ashes and that I regret.

I love all my pets but once in a while there will be one I feel closer to than the others. From now on those pets I will make a memorial to, like an urn. That is of course a personal choice and it only reflects the way I grieve. I am not making a statement that everyone needs to say words or get an urn. I guess it is so hard because pets can't speak and most of it is love but there is some of my imagination thrown in too so loosing a pet is always a hard time.

I think the important thing you might remember is that you always put JP first. His welfare always came first, his happiness always came first, your relationship with him always came first. That is real love and you gave it to him heaped up and puring over.

As far as paying for medical care if I have it I spend it. I no longer care if it is justified or what others might think. I am past that now and I know the value of my pets is beyond price so I dont even wrestle with it anymore.

16
by CathyA on 07/02/2011 12:42pm

My condolences. It's always terribly hard to let go. May he have an easy passing.

17
What price love?
by puppymom on 07/28/2011 01:32am

Dr Lee, I'm so sorry to hear about JP. He was clearly loved and cherished. I faced the same dilemma with my basset girl Scout and chose to fight the battle that I believed would best win the war. Long story short, I'm sure I put several vet students through school at Texas A&M! And I would absolutely do it again, as long as she was happy. The oncologists estimated she would have 6 months to a year. I was able to love my baby girl for two and a half more years before the battle was lost. I loved her enough to let her go when it was clear her quality of life was gone. She was my child and I can't even describe how much I miss her, but I know how lucky I was to have been her person. What I continue to have a hard time with is that even though I was blessed to have two and a half years to say goodbye, it was still not enough time to prepare for what I knew would be the inevitable. Maybe that's the hard part about being the human. We always need more time....

My sympathies to you on the loss of your beloved JP. He was loved and there is nothing greater than that!

18
by gayechrobak on 07/28/2011 09:51pm

I too have a parvo survivor which has segued into inflammatory bowel disease. $8000.00 and nine weeks later I think we are finally seeing the light at the end of the tunnel. He is improving, the protein levels are going up and hopefully, this emotional yo-yo will be over. I don't answer the phone right now because it's bills I can't pay. I will catch up the bills but I could never live with myself if I did not do everything I could do for this dog. This is my fault because he only had two sets of shots and not the four he needed. This has been the hardest lesson I have ever learned. He is a beautiful ten month old rottie who was a gift from the human "grandmother" of my 2 1/2 year old rottie. Money doesn't make the world okay but those faces at the window when I come home certainly do! My dogs are my comfort, just like JP was yours. May God BlessYou for being such a loving good Mommy to that dog.

19
by Dr Justine Lee on 08/02/2011 10:58am

@gayechrobak - Thanks so much for sharing. Amazing how much they grow on us...

I love Rotties also (I favor the "bad breeds"), and so glad you have a wonderful companion in your life!

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.

 


MEET THE VETS

Lorie Huston, DVM is a small animal veterinarian with over 20 years experience...
READ MORE

Patrick Mahaney, VMD is an integrative veterinarian who combines western and eastern perspectives...
READ MORE

Ken Tudor, DVM has a veterinary practice focused exclusively on pet weight loss and management...
READ MORE

Anna O'Brien, DVM is a large animal veterinarian working just outside of Washington, D.C. in Maryland...
READ MORE

Dr. Joanne Intile, DVM, DACVIM is a Cornell trained veterinary oncologist practicing in Maryland…
READ MORE

  • Lifetime Credits:
  • Today's Credits:
Hurry Before All Seats are Taken!
Enroll
Be an A++ Pet Parent! Take fun & free courses to earn badges & certifications. Choose a course»
Subscribe to The Daily Vet

Most Read Daily Vet Articles

Five Common Litter Box Mistakes
If you want to keep your cat using the litter box regularly, caring for your cat’s...
READ MORE
Five Common Mistakes Made by Cat Owners
The average cat owner often overlooks some important aspects of their pet’s health...
READ MORE
The Unnecessary Anger of the Pet Food ...
This week Dr. Ken Tudor addresses the anger pet owners feel when discussing pet...
READ MORE
Top Five Holistic Pet Cancer Prevention Tips
May is Pet Cancer Awareness Month. Today Dr. Patrick Mahaney lists his top five tips...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

The Unnecessary Anger of the Pet Food ...
This week Dr. Ken Tudor addresses the anger pet owners feel when discussing pet...
READ MORE
Consumer Pressure is Changing Livestock ...
The latest publication of the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association...
READ MORE
Top Five Holistic Pet Cancer Prevention Tips
May is Pet Cancer Awareness Month. Today Dr. Patrick Mahaney lists his top five tips...
READ MORE
The Agony of Arthritis – Is Your Cat ...
Since May has been proclaimed Arthritis Awareness Month, it seems a good time to...
READ MORE

PETMD POLL

What do you use to prevent ticks from feeding on your pet?

Spot-on meds
60% (114 votes)
Oral meds
14% (27 votes)
Tick collars
8% (15 votes)
Other
6% (12 votes)
N/A (I do not use tick preventives)
12% (23 votes)
Total votes: 191

Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2013 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved