Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

Time for Another Jerky Treat Update

PrintPrint

October 08, 2012 / (18) comments

Okay, this is the fifth post I’ve written on the canine and feline illnesses that appear to be associated with jerky-style treats imported from China. I didn’t intend to create a timeline for this incident, but if you’re interested in seeing how things have progressed over the last few years, or aren’t familiar with this problem, read the first four pieces in the series and then rejoin us here when you’re done.

 

Problems with Chicken Jerky?

Chicken Jerky Update

More on Chicken Jerky

Jerky Investigation Widens

 

You’re back? Good.

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) posted an update to their website on September 14. I’ve highlighted important new information below:

 

The FDA has received approximately 2,200 reports of pet illnesses which may be related to consumption of the jerky treats [including chicken jerky (treats, tenders, and strips), duck, sweet potato, and treats where chicken or duck jerky is wrapped around dried fruits, sweet potatoes, or yams]. The majority of the complaints involve dogs, but cats also have been affected. Over the past 18 months the reports have contained information on 360 canine deaths and one feline death.

 

A cause has still not been identified, but the FDA’s list of potential contaminants that have been tested for now reads "salmonella, metals, furans, pesticides, antibiotics, mycotoxins, rodenticides, nephrotoxins (such as aristolochic acid, maleic acid, paraquat, ethylene glycol, diethylene glycol, toxic hydrocarbons, melamine, and related triazines) and … other chemicals and poisonous compounds." The FDA has also expanded its testing "to include irradiation byproducts and is consulting with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) experts to discuss this possibility further."

Interesting. Irradiation has been used for years to reduce the risk of food borne illnesses and extend the shelf-life of foods intended for both human and animal consumption. If you’re interested in learning more about the subject, Wikipedia actually has a really good entry on food irradiation that includes a section about an incident in Australia, when 16 cats developed lesions in their brains and spinal cords and were euthanized as a result of eating a certain brand of cat food. The manufacturer mentioned irradiation as a possible cause, but investigations never determined the reason behind the illnesses. Australia did subsequently ban the practice of irradiating imported cat foods.

One comment that keeps coming up in response to all the current problems with jerky treats is, "Why hasn’t there been a recall of these products?" The FDA answers the question this way:

 

There is nothing preventing a company from conducting a voluntary recall. It is important to understand that unless a contaminant is detected and we have evidence that a product is adulterated, we are limited in what regulatory actions we can take. The regulations don't allow for products to be removed based on complaints alone. This is an ongoing investigation and FDA will notify the public if a recall is initiated. Currently, FDA continues to urge pet owners to use caution with regard to jerky pet treat products.

 

I’ll do more than "urge pet owners to use caution." Don’t feed your pets any type of jerky made in China until this problem is resolved.

 

 

Dr. Jennifer Coates

 

 

Image: No Jerky Treats / composite from images sourced from Shutterstock

 

Subscribe to The Daily Vet
COMMENTS (18)
1
Recalls
by TheOldBroad on 10/08/2012 06:57am

I confess that I'm surprised that these products are still being sold. Surely with all the attention jerky treats from China have gotten people shouldn't be buying them.

It people would stop buying them, stores would stop selling them.

It frightens me that these products are still on the shelves.

by CP on 10/09/2012 02:53pm

It doesn't surprise me that people still buy them. I wonder how many people truly listen to the news. When the massive pet recall was all over the news a few years ago, a waitress in a local restaurant (pet owner too)hadn't heard of it. If people are unaware of an issue that was highly publicized it makes sense that this situation goes unnoticed by many pet owners.

2
China Dog Treats
by djordan on 10/08/2012 09:04am

Most all the treats in petstores and convience stores are treats made in China, because it is cheeper to produce and cannot compete with the taxes and regulations over food produces in the US. It's almost impossible to find treats not made in China. What I don't understand is why the government allows imported foods (including those for animals) and does not hold them to the same standards as what industries in our same country must abide by. Their plants should be inspected by USDA (or whoever approves the product in the US) same as an industry in the US. If this were done much of what is happening now would never happen. It is possible that something is going into these treats (be it accidental or otherwise) that would then be caught if they were inspected and held to the same regulations. Where as it may never be caught 'searching' for it in the ready made product because you have KNOW what you're looking for after the product is made and packaged. How would one go about beginning that campaign?

by lupuslady on 10/09/2012 07:37am

NPR had a great news story on food being imported here in the US from China. It was interview with a USDA inspector. He said that with the huge numbers of imported food products just for humans that they barely put a dent in what they can get to and check.
In the news story it said how tea leaves for human consumption are dried by using car engines and other horrible ways...cut costs etc. The USDA inspector said that usually they get tips on food products that are so spoiled not fit for rat consumption. He flat out said that he, himself does not buy any food product that is made even part of it, from China because their guide lines are so poor.
So USDA I am sure, puts pet food near bottom for inspecting due to lack of people to do inspections.
I have noticed now that some of jerky products are saying made in USA but when you read back in small print it says chicken product is from China so read back print in ingredients closely. They can do this legally if they import products but put it together here in the US. So read the ingredients ...just search very closely for word China. Also USDA web site has great info on this and is asking both pet owners and Vets to report any illness that maybe from jerky products. So I feel they are trying and doing their best with limited man power they employed for years now.
Zack dog treats, I believe, are made completely with US products. Newman's is excellent brand period...human grade organic in all their products.
So just think that if this is making some dogs sick...about all the human food that Americans are consuming from China, makes you wonder about all cancer people get.
I would urge all people to try and listen to that NPR story ...i know it still was available if you search for it just a few months ago. USDA definitely needs more people inspecting...the inspector interviewed you could hear his frustration at not being able to check more ships etc. Listen to it...it is must hear interview!

3
Jerky treats
by Kayteenm on 10/08/2012 09:28am

I agree..just stop buying the treats and there won't be a market for them anymore.
I make my own jerky treats. That way I know what's in them and I don't have to worry about anything.

4
Complex situation
by Tomcat on 10/08/2012 09:34am

First, thanks, Dr. Coates, for continuing to share this information. It is highly needed and we are trying to do our part at the Veterinary News Network with our recent story release on this as well.

Before I go further, let me state that, without question, I do believe that there is an issue here. These treats ARE causing some sort of issue, but we have to look at just how complicated this whole thing is.

I agree with TheOldBroad in that seeing the treats on the shelves scares me. BUT...the simple fact of the matter is that until some sort of causality can be determined, there is nothing to force the companies to order a recall. AND, by looking at their sites, it's obvious that these companies have a lot of faith in their particular product, so why would they want to recall it? Recalling their product, if nothing is wrong with it, would be like saying we need to stop all construction of new swimming pools because of the fact that a small number of children have wandered into pools and drowned. The situation is much more complex.

I read somewhere this weekend that more than 15 million of these products are sold each year. So, the 2200 reports generated divided by product sold means that less than 2 pets out of every thousand are being affected. Could this also be a genetic/environmental/other cause type of issue?? If you review the FDA log of complaints, you will find that a fair number of the reports do not include any visit to the veterinarian OR diagnostics. Someone just saw their dog vomit/have diarrhea/become lethargic after having the treats and made the immediate "cause then effect" assumption. Some of these pets have NEVER been to a veterinarian, so we know that the 2200 reports may reflect a certain number (10%, 20%) where the jerky treats are not really the issue.

As to djordan's comments....the FDA did go do inspections of the Chinese plants and did not find enough substantial evidence to pinpoint anything. One plant was using too much proplylene glycol (I think) but that is supposed to be rectified now. The Chinese did, however, refuse to allow samples of the ingredients to be brought back to the US for testing (they would only allow testing in their labs) so that is a big red flag for me. Also, the government allows these foods in because (as above) they can't find a problem and 2) people demand it. People are looking for the least expensive products (Not just dog treats) and we continue to accept sub-standard products because we want to get that great deal. Do we remember that it made our pets sick or that the product broke after 3 months? Nope...we just go out and buy another one.

We need to continue to chat/blog/video comments about this story and beg/plead/cajole your pet loving neighbors to stop buying these products. Show them homemade recipes or websites of truly 100% USA made and sourced products.

5
Dog Treats
by freshanje on 10/08/2012 09:40am

As long as people keep buying these treats from China the stores will keep selling them. It amazes me watching people in the stores just pick up a package and put it in their cart without looking at where it's made or what is in it. All these people think is "it's cheap". I did find a chicken jerky made in USA called Nudges, but not all stores carry them yet. Found them at Meijers.

6
Jerky Treats
by Chrstine on 10/08/2012 12:14pm

I get my puppies treats from the place where my sister bought my puppy for me. They are the ones that have chicken wrapped around carrots or sweet potato. He loves them.
They are made from all organic ingredients.
AHere is the info on one of the packages to give you an idea of what they are.
I also read on another package that they are tested and developed @ Cornel Research Center.
OK, Here's the one I have in my hand right now:
This one is not w/ chicken but from the same company.
Chicken treats form from same company as this:
------------------------------------------------------
As printed on Lables:
ANIMAL WELLNESS HEALTH TREATS
100% DIGESTABLE - MADE IN USA
VETERINARIAN RECOMMENDED
WWW.ANIMALWELLNESSFOUNDATION.COM

100% ORGANIC PEANUT BUTTER VETERINARIAN RECOMMENDED
WITH GLUCOLSAMINE & CHONDROITIN
www. AnimalWellnessFoundation.com
_____________________________________________________
They also make a cheese flavor treat with same ingredients, only w/ cheese. My puppy personally prefers the peanut butter, but he loves mostly all the treats from this company.
You can order your dogs treats, I believe, from this site. I haven't visited it yet but I'm sure that's where you can purhase them.
I hope it's helpful. I'm going to visit the site as soon as I'm done here.
It's all made here in the USA and I havent' had any problems with my puppy so far in giving him these treats. I avoid buying anything edible if I can help it, from CHINA. They don't have the safety regulations we have here in the USA so why give it to our pets if we wouldn't eat it ourselves?
Again, I hope this is helpful to others in buying the highest quality pet treats for your pets needs.
Thank you, Doctor, for emailing updates on the Jerkey Treats. It's a much needed update for the safety of our pets.
Thank you for watching out for all of us.
Much appreciated!!!

7
Reason v Duty
by oh holland on 10/08/2012 12:26pm

I appreciate TomCat's well reasoned post ^. A well-known scientific principle is that "correlation does not imply cause." Jerky treats from China having been consumed by pets who become ill doesn't prove the treats are the cause -- BUT -- I believe pet owners have an overriding duty to not risk their pet's health when there is good reason to suspect the cause, and Chinese treats should be off the table (or out of the bowl, as it were.)

In fact, I go a step further and will not buy ANY jerky for my pets, whether or not they are made in China. It's not something my dogs require and there are plenty of safe substitutes. I say nothing beats a good old fashioned (real) marrow bone.

8
Jerdy Treats Continued...
by Chrstine on 10/08/2012 12:52pm

I just visited the Wellness site that I posted about up above. This is the link for the Home Page so please visit when you have a few minutes:
Home page:

http://animalwellnessfoundation.com/

They have everything from food, treats, suppliments, ADVICE ect... for a healthy pet &
***IT'S ALL HOLISTIC*** and very healthy for your pet.

I see all the products here that I use for my own pet.
The treats, Nutra Drops which is very good for pets who have low glucose and high stress.
I add it to food and to his water.
I have a Chihushua and they have a tendency at times to have glucose levels drop which can be fatal if not treated asap. I put 2 to 3cc's in a suringe (1/2 tspn) and right into his mouth. Goes right into his blood stream w/in seconds. It's much better than giving them sugar which can increase their weight. It's high calary formula w/ B vitamins but gies directly into their blood streams and they don't have to digest it like regular table sugar.
My dog is on the Health Extention Diet and he loves it.
My Veterinarian was very impressed when he asked me what diet Monroe is on. He said it's a wonderful diet and they have wonderful products to offer pets.
He very highly recommended it.

Again I hope this helps others.

9
To Reason vs Duty
by Chrstine on 10/08/2012 02:05pm

Just a note to you...
I had asked my Veterinarian as well as other pet heath professionals about giving my dogs bones to chew on rathe rthan artifically flavored treats and chews and all said:

"DO NOT GIVE YOUR DOGS ANY NATURAL BONES FROM YOUR STEAK OR ANY OTHER MEATS BECAUSE THEY SPLINTER.
WE'VE HAD TOO MANY ANIMALS COME INTO MY OFFICE BECAUSE THEY WERE GIVEN A STEAK BONE TO CHEW AND IT SPLINTERED CAUSING INTERNAL CUTS AND ANAL BLEEDING.
tOO MANY SMALL FRAGMENTS GET CAUGHT INSIDE AND MANY CAN'T BE SAVED ONCE THE DAMAGE IS DONE."

This was told to us about 10 eyars ago and I never gave any of my pets natural bones again.
I know they chew them in the wild, but they aren't cooked or heated in any way.

Just sayin~

by oh holland on 10/09/2012 09:44am

Thanks, Christine, for your good caution. I only give my dogs raw bones -- should've said so.

by Chrstine on 10/09/2012 07:36pm

You're very welcome. I think it's good to share what we know with others w/ the same concerns.
We all have so many questions at times. It's good to share what we know with other so we can save oru pets undo grief.
Glad to help.

10
Made in China Treats
by HawaiiHorses on 10/08/2012 03:08pm

Economics 101: Don't buy it.

by Chrstine on 10/09/2012 07:44pm

BOTTOM LINE!!!

11
by redkitty1 on 10/09/2012 04:30pm

This may be slightly off topic, but my son almost bought antlers at a flea market last weekend (I've been telling him about antlers as dog chews) - I told him no, because I had questions about diseases that might be passed from the antlers. Could that be a problem?

by Chrstine on 10/09/2012 07:43pm

I would imagine that they are treated and steralized before being sold. I have a problem with items not being wrapped and protected from so many hands touching them. I hate the thought of buying an item for my dog or any of my other pets and knowing that dirty hands have been all over them. I worry about that too. I always worry as you do about the spread of any parasites or bachteria on loose items.
I've been getting my puppy those Bully sticks. He seems to really like them.
I think your best bet would be to ask your Veterinarian. Maybe they know more about how these things are processed than we do. I don't always trust the seller becasue they will say anything to make a sale. I think my first question would be where did the antlers come from?

by Dr. Jennifer Coates on 10/10/2012 11:13am

I recently saw some for sale at a farmers market (wow, were they expensive!) I know chronic wasting disease can be passed through elk antler velvet - the risk from the antlers themselves... probably pretty small.

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.

 



About fully vetted

Jennifer Coates, DVM

Photo of Dr Coates

Image credit: Jim Piraino

...graduated with honors from the Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary Medicine in 1999. In the years since, she has practiced veterinary medicine in Virginia, Wyoming, and Colorado. She is the author of several books about veterinary medicine and animal care, including the Dictionary of Veterinary Terms: Vet-Speak Deciphered for the Non-Veterinarian. Dr. Coates also writes short stories that focus on the strength and importance of the human-animal bond, and freelance articles relating to a variety of animal care and veterinary topics. Dr. Coates lives in Fort Collins, Colorado with her husband, daughter, and various species of pets.

  • Lifetime Credits:
  • Today's Credits:
Hurry Before All Seats are Taken!
Enroll
Be an A++ Pet Parent! Take fun & free courses to earn badges & certifications. Choose a course»
Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Dog Panting – Normal or Not?
Dogs pant. They pant when they’re hot, they pant when they’re excited, they pant...
READ MORE
The Truth About Pit Bulls: Part 1
Dr. Jennifer Coates has written before about breed specific legislation. Today she...
READ MORE
How to ... Make a Dog Vomit
In today’s Fully Vetted, inducing emesis in dogs, or in laymen’s terms, making a...
READ MORE
Stories from Vet School Will Keep Pride at ...
The saying “a little knowledge is a dangerous thing” can certainly apply to veterinary...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

The Truth About Pit Bulls: Part 2
In part 2 of Dr. Jennifer Coates’s discussion on the Pit Bull breed, she discounts...
READ MORE
It’s Difficult to Regulate Diabetics
Difficult to manage diabetic patients end up on unusually high doses of insulin but...
READ MORE
Dogs and Cats Get Bipartisan Support
Pet owners in Colorado have reason to celebrate this month, after two new bills were...
READ MORE
The Truth About Pit Bulls: Part 1
Dr. Jennifer Coates has written before about breed specific legislation. Today she...
READ MORE

PETMD POLL

What do you use to prevent ticks from feeding on your pet?

Spot-on meds
60% (132 votes)
Oral meds
15% (32 votes)
Tick collars
7% (16 votes)
Other
6% (13 votes)
N/A (I do not use tick preventives)
12% (27 votes)
Total votes: 220

Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance


MORE FROM PETMD.COM