Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

 

Are Our Pets Capable of Loving Us?

PrintPrint

December 06, 2012 / (9) comments


Today we are reprinting one of Dr. Coates's blog posts from this past February on the topic of whether animals, and more specifically, our pets, are capable of emotional love. If you missed it then, read her take on the issue today, and then join the conversation with your own comments and experiences with love and your pets.

 

I just had an interesting conversation with the manager of my horse’s new barn. We were swapping stories and our outlooks on all things equine when he said, "I think one of the biggest mistakes that people make is thinking that their horses love them." I’m sure I made some sort of noncommittal reply, but after we parted ways I gave the comment deeper thought. Does my horse love me? I don’t think he does.

Don’t get me wrong, he is very attached to me, and I’m not the only one who has said so. I had to take him in to a veterinary referral hospital for some dental work a while back, and the technicians mentioned it after he kept looking over his shoulder whinnying at me as they led him away. When we are together he is usually kind and playful and seems genuinely happy that I’m there. After we’ve been apart, he’s either excited to see me or sulky if I’ve been gone too long. I love him, but I think he sees me more as a source of good things like grooming, fun outings and food, as well as a protector. This doesn’t necessarily equal love.

I define love in this situation as a willingness to put someone else’s best interests in front of your own. I don’t think Atticus is capable of doing that. He has injured me (never seriously and always unintentionally) when he’s been scared because he is focused solely on self-preservation. I chalk this up to horses being prey animals. When push comes to shove, they fall back on an "everyone is out to get me" point of view. I remember one time when I fell off Atticus after he over-reacted to some perceived threat. After he realized his mistake, he sheepishly walked over to me, putting his nose on my shoulder. He looked genuinely sorry to find me in a heap on the ground, but I doubt that he had the slightest concern for my well-being in the heat of the moment.

Do my cats love me? I smile even as I ask that question. It brings to mind the quote, "Dogs have owners; cats have staff." I do not doubt that others have different relationships with their cats, but mine seem to view me as I suspect the aristocracy looks upon their faithful servants — with affection, but that’s as far as it goes.

Dogs are another story altogether. Too many dogs have put their own well-being at risk to help their people to discount the possibility that love plays a role in that relationship. I’ve never been in mortal danger, but I did have a dog protect me from a stick once. Before you laugh, let me defend my dog by saying this was one scary sounding stick.

I was walking down the side of the road with my dachshund-beagle-corgi named Owen when I accidentally kicked a smallish branch covered in dry leaves. It made a horrendous cracking-scratching-rattling noise. Owen jumped in front of me with fangs bared, fur raised, and eyes shining with hate tinged by a little fear, ready to protect me from the evil beastie that dared threaten his person. I was so proud of my little guy! I made a big fuss over him to ease his embarrassment after he realized what the "threat" really was.

So, what do you think? Do your animals love you?

 

 

Dr. Jennifer Coates

 

 

Image: Dog meet boy, boy meet dog by Dr. Nomad / via Flickr

 

Subscribe to Fully Vetted
COMMENTS (9)
1
Cats Have Staff
by TheOldBroad on 12/06/2012 06:56am

Sadly, I have to agree that "Cats have Staff".

My herd greets me at the door and the entire herd follows me from room to room. They keep my lap warm and cuddle at night.

However, I'm afraid that if someone else took my place, I don't doubt that after the new person had been in the house for a few days, the herd would act the same toward them.

I think they love the "giver of all things", but I believe they would quickly adjust to a new "giver of all things".

2
Cats Have Staff
by Lisha Barnes on 12/06/2012 10:39am

As humans, we all want to be loved and I think we want to be loved. I am going to continue to believe that all of my animals love me unconditionally because that's how they make me feel. Even though my husband is also the "giver of all things" the same as me, all of our animals prefer me over him with the exception of one kitty and she will let you know that she belongs to him. However, we both love them all the same and provide for them the same.

3
Dogs
by VetsRock on 12/06/2012 01:01pm

Do my dogs love me? I think so - but each of our 4 shows it differently. I've never been in mortal danger either but the more confident ones will protect me from scary things too... And I have learned to pay attention to their behavior because they are a great judge of people. When we are on walks they only react to people who aren't usually in our neighborhood - or in one case when we were at the park and there were a couple people making a drug deal in the parking lot.

We have one dog that is pretty shy and she is more likely to show her love by trusting that I will protect HER from scary things.

4
Do your animals love you?
by JurisGal on 12/06/2012 02:36pm

Yes. Yes they do.

5
Cats
by UFOH1 on 12/06/2012 08:07pm

I have owned well over 60 cats. In that time only 2 could I say "loved" me. The rest were affectionate but on their terms.

Spooky, a white Persian, was a bear with anyone but me. When moving cross country someone attempted to break into our car while we were eating lunch. The side window was broken and whoever met one very irate cat! Nothing was taken but it took another hour before she unfluffed and stopped growling. Sure would have liked to have seen the expression on "whoever" when she attacked! :)

The other was a stray kitten that I found. She was an incredible cat. She knew when I was coming home and would sit by the door and greet me. Someone let her out one day and she was killed by the dog next door. I was heartbroken.

6
Does it matter?
by Evelyn Tan on 12/06/2012 09:23pm

Personally it doesn't matter to me if my cats love me, like me, or simply tolerate me . As long as I love and protect them, that's enough. I don't ask for anything in return, except for them to be healthy and happy in their short lives.

7
Unconditional love
by Drken on 12/07/2012 07:43pm

I have tried unsuccessfully for 2 1/2 years to enact legislation,Gracie's Law, allowing for capped non economic damages when a pet is killed through negligence or malice. I am a veterinarian. My biggest opposition has come from my own profession who say that your pet is family when they want you to spend thousands for treatment, but believe that they have no value when killed. The fact that you would ask this question explains a lot. Pets are sentient beings. They love their pet parents unconditionally. You should not be a veterinarian if you do not understand this. Please see Gracie's Law-Pets are Family on Facebook for more information.

8
of course they can
by luvmygirly on 12/08/2012 05:25pm

of course our furry family members are very capable of loving us.they do every day in different ways.not 1 animal(just like not 1 person)shows love in each individual ways.they love,feel pain and loss.they just express their feelings in ways different than people,but every things different. babygirl has shown me(along with all the other animal family member's that i've been blessed to have be part of my entire life) unwavering devotion,love,respect and kindness.quality's i have yet to see in any person.to me the value of an animal life and a human life are equal.

9
My experience says yes.
by andishine on 12/27/2012 07:25pm

I fully agree with those who point out cats have staff. They might have "preferred" staff, but it's still staff, nonetheless.

Dogs are harder, but I think they really do. They are clearly driven by a pack mentality that causes them to look out for all the members (and if it's just you and the dog, well, you get all the focus). But there is no doubt that while my human family members are also part of the pack, my dog misses me if I am out-of-town and is particularly happy to see me return. While I am away, he is much more at peace when he is comforted by a worn t-shirt of mine in his bed than he is if I forget. This is but one example, but it is one where it is easy to make sure all other things are equal, and yet he still misses me in a way that can only be interpreted as the way you miss someone you love.

Beyond that, I can tell you that horses DEFINITIVELY feel love. Their bonds to their friends, whether four- or two-legged are profound. I have probably hundreds of illustrations I can make (both large and small), but let me make two...

When I was in college, a friend was barn-sitting over the holidays when an electrical short set the hay barn on fire. There were two horses housed in that building as well, both of whom perished. The dam of one of these geldings (who was 8 or 9, if memory serves correctly) was stalled in a barn about 50 yards away, and she went berserk during the fire, screaming and rearing in her stall. She was not a nervous mare, and not even the nervous horses in that barn reacted that way. In the days that followed, she was depressed and whinnied often in the direction of the burned barn when she was turned out. She and her son had not been kept in the same building or even turned out adjacent to each other in years, so how do you explain this if not love?

In one of countless personal experiences, after a horse show I had been at with a yearling mare that I had raised, I sent her home with a trainer that was there so that she could be prepped for our World Championship show. Six weeks later I flew from home in CO to the trainer's in CA to take photos for the ad we would be running, and when I opened her stall door, the filly's eyes got so big and she ran over and stuck her face against my belly (it brings tears to my eyes to think about, even now!) She was not abused or mistreated in any way while she was there, so this could not be some sort of relief to see me; and it was just sheer happiness I felt from her. Later that night I sneaked out to the barn after dinner and found her laying sternal in her straw (she couldn't be bedded on shavings). I went in and sat with her, and she quickly laid her head in my lap and fell asleep in a manner I had never seen from her. That mare later went two weeks beyond her foaling due date with her first (something my mares did not do, for several management reasons), until one evening that I decided on a hunch to go sit with her in her stall. An hour later, she was in clear labor and an hour after that she had a colt standing by her side. Coincidence?? Maybe... ;)

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.

 


About fully vetted

Jennifer Coates, DVM

Photo of Dr Coates

Image credit: Jim Piraino

...graduated with honors from the Virginia-Maryland Regional College of Veterinary Medicine in 1999. In the years since, she has practiced veterinary medicine in Virginia, Wyoming, and Colorado. She is the author of several books about veterinary medicine and animal care, including the Dictionary of Veterinary Terms: Vet-Speak Deciphered for the Non-Veterinarian. Dr. Coates also writes short stories that focus on the strength and importance of the human-animal bond, and freelance articles relating to a variety of animal care and veterinary topics. Dr. Coates lives in Fort Collins, Colorado with her husband, daughter, and various species of pets.

  • Lifetime Credits:
  • Today's Credits:
Hurry Before All Seats are Taken!
Enroll
Be an A++ Pet Parent! Take fun & free courses to earn badges & certifications. Choose a course»
Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Why Large Dogs Die Young
When Dr. Coates was on vacation a couple of months ago, she posted a link to an article...
READ MORE
It's a Boy!
Dr. Coates has a new pet member of the family. His name is Bernie, and he’s a Betta.
READ MORE
An Early Start to Allergy Season
If your dog or cat has increased the amount of scratching, licking, and chewing,...
READ MORE
Lucky Number 13: Rottweilers as Guide Dogs to...
Veterinarians at the Murphy Foundation’s Center for Exceptional Longevity Studies...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

A Couple of Law Updates
In today’s Fully Vetted, Dr. Coates updates readers regarding developments on two...
READ MORE
Preventing Heartworm Disease
Dr. Coates has written many times about heartworm disease but today she thought she’d...
READ MORE
Breaking the Law, Breaking the Law
Veterinarians need your help; many of them are currently on the lam from the DEA....
READ MORE
An 'Intrigue' of Kittens
Dr. Jennifer Coates found herself stumped last week when trying to remember the name...
READ MORE

PETMD POLL

What do you use to prevent ticks from feeding on your pet?

Spot-on meds
60% (113 votes)
Oral meds
14% (26 votes)
Tick collars
8% (15 votes)
Other
6% (12 votes)
N/A (I do not use tick preventives)
11% (21 votes)
Total votes: 187

Subscribe to petMD Blogs

Never miss a single post!

Fully Vetted
The Daily Vet
Nutrition Nuggets
Purely Puppy
Healthy Assurance
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2013 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved