Subscribe to
Fully Vetted
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

 

Is your pet hungry or does she just want more food?

November 18, 2010 / (8) comments


This is a tough question; a really tough one for a great many of my clients. But it’s not rocket science, so here’s my simple prescription: 

 

If your pet is overweight, reduce the amount you feed her by a teensy bit every week until you can see the pounds start coming off. Maintain this food volume until she has reached a normal weight. Once she has, you might find that giving her a little more is OK. And voilá! You now possess a bona fide veterinarian-approved diet.

Some pets require more exercise, some less. Some demand extra attention to detail (fat cats, for example, should not lose weight too precipitously). But all healthy pets — without exception — have the capacity to attain normal weights on this simple calorie-restricted regimen.

As for so many popular human diets that rightfully claim effectiveness, many pet food companies claim that weight loss will be best achieved by feeding their "specially formulated" diet. And they may be right. But I find it’s way simpler to stick to the concept of "calories in = calories out."

Which means that the amount of calories an animal consumes must equal the amount of calories the animal expends — that is, if weight maintenance is desired. If weight loss is the goal, calories in must be less than calories out.

Makes sense, right? And yet it’s not so intuitive. Why? Because nothing rational stands up to this common utterance: "But she’s so hungry all the time!"

At this point, it’s my role to calmly explain that the notion of "hunger" is something they should probably re-examine. Because being "hungry" is a very different thing from wanting food. 

We can all glean these basics from our own personal experience: Food tastes good, so we eat more. And we "overdo it" a lot (take, for example, next week’s Thanksgiving festivities). We even experience severe, life-threatening effects related to our overindulgence. Yet, we continue to eat more. 

From the medical point of view, we’ve also come to the understanding that a barrage of hormones are released when we’re hungry, when we smell food, and then when we eat it — all of which affects our total caloric intake. 

When we eat, hormones are released, letting our body’s key stakeholder parts know that we’re full-up and can stop eating. But if we eat too fast our hormones don’t get the chance to deliver the memo in time. So we keep eating. And it seems that the memo can be similarly delayed when we consume certain kinds of food. So we keep eating … until the message gets through.

Alternatively, another memo may be responsible for requesting greater intakes of food. But science-wise, we’re still kind of fuzzy on these hormonal messages and their triggers. Otherwise, we might actually have a fighting chance at curbing the obesity epidemic a bit better than we’re currently managing. 

In the absence of clear directives, I’ll admit it can all be a bit confusing. Yet the upshot should be obvious: As a culture, we Americans are a whole lot less "hungry" than we think we are — which really should help inform how we treat our pets. And yet, we clearly share a collective interpretation of our pets' hunger. Otherwise they would not be tipping the scales as they are in ever increasing numbers.

Yes, a full 50 percent of our pets are overweight or obese, according to the Association for Pet Obesity Prevention. And is it any wonder? After all, our pets seem to be well aware of the old biblical adage that those who demand will be rewarded with greater spoils for their trouble. And since food = love for so many U.S. households, this hungrified pet trend is showing no signs of abating.

 

 

Dr. Patty Khuly

 

 

Pic of the day: "cracker - 113/365" by diegodiazphotography

Subscribe to Fully Vetted
COMMENTS (8)
1
Pet obesity
by on 11/18/2010 06:33am

Unfortunately my veterinarian got mad at me when my 12 year old dog didn't lose weight instead of checking her thyroid levels. By the time she was really sick her thyroid level was zero and she died within 3 weeks.

2
Free Feeding
by on 11/18/2010 07:39am


My kitties have several "buffets" throughout the house. Yes, several are chubby. Some are not.

What I've noticed is that those who have previously been on the streets (and no doubt hungry) are the ones with a few extra pounds. I suspect a "stray mentality" to food: Eat what's there because you don't know when you're going to get to eat again.

I can't imagine the fear of not knowing when the next meal might be.

I also suspect that a couple with serious health problems have fought a little longer because they had weight to lose. At least I don't have the guilt that any of the health problems were weight related. At least not yet.

3
Weight Loss
by on 11/18/2010 11:16am

The addition of a new kitten has helped Max (The Hulk) lose weight. He's eating about the same but is now playing like crazy with Rainbow. His exercise time has increased exponentially. Before he played just a bit even though he's only 3. Highly recommend this approach!

4
Over weight Pets
by on 11/18/2010 11:55am

That is a hard one, so far my older ones are keeping thier pounds down, but as they age, we have to cut back.

5
by on 11/18/2010 12:32pm

A protein calorie does not equal a fat calorie does not equal a carb calorie.

To even suggest so in this day and age and with all the science we have to the contrary - what a ridiculous statement to make.

And yes, if you're feeding the wrong food, even at a proper weight your pet may be feeling extreme hunger. We crave foods when our body craves nutrients, right? Well, when the food you feed says you need to feed five cups to satisfy your dog's weight but he actually needs two, those are not only calories he is missing, those are nutrients.

Does it take a very long time to develop a nutritional deficiency? Generally, yes. But it doesn't mean the dog doesn't feel hunger when he isn't receiving proper nutrition.

Find a moderate to high protein, moderate to low fat, low carb food that is heavily meat based (or even better, a balanced home made diet or raw diet) and feed exactly as you suggested. Slowly reduce until you're happy. Will you have some protesting? Probably. I find raw knuckle bones are great distractions, as are Kongs stuffed with cooked veggies, mashed and frozen.

6
Weight Loss Achieved!
by on 11/18/2010 12:52pm

I'm SO glad that you tackled the weight loss issue in pets! I see so many obese pets these days, and it's really something that pet parents need to address.

My dogs were becoming overweight on a free feed diet. We started it because the dogs seemed to be able to manage their eating habits--at first. But, as they grew older, I realized that they used food the way many humans do--as means to quell boredom.

The solution? I stopped free feeding and took matters into my own hands.

Feeding dogs what the dog food manufacturers recommend doesn't work. Their instructions only amount to a "guideline". I had to learn to gauge how much food my dogs NEEDED. Our eldest, a Shiba, is very active, but apparently she has a relatively low metabolic rate, because she gains weight at the drop of a hat. Our min pin is a nervous Nellie who frets and fidgets her weight away. Finally, our chihuahua has an oral fixation. She will (and does) eat just about everything in sight, and licks all of the other pets bowls clean after she's eaten her own food.

Now I feed the dogs myself, twice a day. To see the tiny amount of food in their bowls you'd think I was starving them. I'm not. They're all very close to ideal weight (if anything, I err on the side of caution and allow them to be a teensy bit on the pudgy side). I can feel their ribs now. Our eldest dog can now sit with her legs under her, not splayed out to the sides. Our min pin has her lovely, svelte figure again, and our chihuahua is no longer jokingly referred to as "no-neck Chavez".

I can openly admit now that the reason my dogs were overweight was due to MY lack of discipline. I was too lazy to take the time to assess their dietary needs. Now they are on good quality food, their intake is limited to only what they need (accounting for a midday treat now and then). They're all happy, healthier, more active, and amazingly, more attentive. :)

7
Are your clients thin?
by on 11/18/2010 01:52pm

Well, Doc, with human obesity (not just FAT) nearing 42% of our population, I'm guessing that your clients could learn about themselves from this post.

The people with weight issues have that constant feeling of need for food, so of course does their pet!

Some of us get it. Most do not seem to.

I heard a saying that I know to be true...

"Nothing tastes as good as being fit feels."

Keep up the valiant efforts!
Carolyn

8
by on 11/18/2010 06:50pm

Food surely means a lot to animals and it was through food they bonded with us in the first place.

I read somewhere, that unlike us, dogs actually don't feel hunger until they start eating ...?

As for us, I think it's an evolutionary glitch from times when food was scarce. Our situation has changed but our brains did not.

I remember both of my grannies giving mom heck for my being too skinny and everybody making me keep eating when I didn't want to any more.

Both grannies had been through WWII. Rules were different then. Same as in the prehistoric times, the rule was simple: eat while you can.

Being fat equaled better chance of survival.

Is it possible that this instinct still remains? Fat was a picture of well-being while skinny was a picture of sickness.

Apart from all that, and I don't know how true this may or may not be, I read claims that some of the fast foods for example include additives that promote hunger and make people addicted to it.

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.


About fully vetted

Patty Khuly, VMD, MBA

Photo of Dr Khuly

Dr. Khuly is a former petMD blogger and small animal veterinarian in Miami, Florida, where she practices medicine at Sunset Animal Clinic and serves on the board of the South Florida Veterinary Medical Association. She is a graduate of Wellesley College, the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and The Wharton School of Business.

As a significant sideline, she writes...a lot. She authors pet health columns for USA Today, The Miami Herald and Vetstreet. She also writes a popular monthly column for Veterinary Practice News and serves as regular contributor to Veterinary Economics, The Bark, and the Veterinary News Network.

Dr. Khuly lives in South Miami with her brood of hens, goats, dogs, cats...and humans.

Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Check Your Pet Food Bags!
The recall of pet foods manufactured at a Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, S.C....
READ MORE
No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Any Dog Can Bite
May 20-26 is National Dog Bite Prevention Week. Being bitten is just one of the...
READ MORE
A New Link Between Pet and Human Health
A study appearing in the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases points to a new link...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Does Horse Racing Deserve Your Support?
I breathed a big sigh of relief on the evening of Saturday, May 5. The 138th running...
READ MORE
Maggots: Thumbs Up or Down?
The weather is starting to heat up here in Colorado, which means that any day...
READ MORE
Palliative Care ≠ Murder
I talked yesterday about compassion fatigue, which often develops when caregivers...
READ MORE
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2012 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved
x
Stay informed about your pet's health...and more!