Subscribe to
Fully Vetted
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

 

Score One For the Bull

May 25, 2010 / (22) comments


Last Saturday offered us one of those occasionally incongruous spectacles in the world of bullfighting, a moment where the tables were turned and the bull won (WARNING: Pictures found in the link are graphic). Yet despite his success, team human still won the day (no surprise) with a series of quick jabs to the bull while matador Julio Aparicio made his way out of the arena, blood gushing down his chin.

Bullfighting sucks. It's a rigged game where even if the bull wins, he loses. Here are some excerpts from an upcoming column for USA Today on how noxiously this so-called "sport" reeks … all the way from across the pond.



Sometimes it takes a prodigious taste for gore to drive home the obvious: You mess with the bull, you get the horns. That bit of Breakfast Club wisdom was strikingly in evidence over the weekend when Spanish matador Julio Aparicio got himself gored in the throat during a bullfight in Madrid.

Over the weekend, this chin-impaling, jawbone-shattering, tongue-lacerating, palate-piercing wounding was roundly regaled as among the most horrific scenes bullfighting has yet offered its normally blood-comfortable audience.

...And though I can muster some sadness for this man who finds himself in critical condition — more so for his family — I keep being drawn back to the one thought that somehow brings me actual comfort in the wake of this disgusting news: Score one for the bull.

...In Spain and throughout Latin America, much has historically been made of the magnificence of a ritual in which the bull’s grace is glorified and the spectacle of his death offered up as a final touch of melodrama. Ask for an explanation and you’ll get the standard response: The bullfight is undertaken to demonstrate profound respect for all the bull offers. To pay homage to the power and the dignity of the beast … because he's earned his one last chance to fight for his freedom.

And yet for all the majesty and grandeur of the corrida, and a bull’s opportunity to fight in the splendor of the arena, make no mistake … this fight is rigged in more ways than you might imagine.

Gone are the days where the bull that lorded over his field for a decade or more was chosen, Ferdinand-style, to strut his stuff in the arena. He’s now been replaced by a purpose-bred animal whose life behind the scenes as a glorious breeding bull is nothing more than a fiction that survives only because most people don’t know where their food comes from … or because they simply like the idea of bloodied bulls and reckless dudes dressed up like Olympic ice skaters.

The real bulls? They’re few and far between and worth way too much to waste on all but perhaps the superbowl of bullfighting. They spend their days of glory shtupping phantom cows into gloved hands armed with plastic pipettes for maximum semen collectability. The widespread application of artificial insemination (yes, even in tradition-bound Spain) means one bull for every few thousand cows and precious few pastured specimens whose demise deserves extra-grotesque orchestration.



There is no point to bullfighting anymore is what I conclude (if there ever was one). And for those who believe that the sport should be preserved for tradition's sake, here's my recommendation: If they're so dead set on depicting honor and glory, why not make it a fair fight?

At the very least, bullfight devotees with a hankering for a bit of weekend bloodlust should clamor for some simple justice in their sport. If the bull scores, he's spared. Anything less means resorting to stealing a cheap victory for the sake of a bad cut of beef. But then, any way you slice it … bullfighting's pathetic.

 

Dr. Patty Khuly

 

 

Art of the day: "STOP BULLFIGHTING! / Tauromaquia Abolición!" by Ardi Beltza. This was a photo taken at a demonstration staged at the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao this past January

 

Subscribe to Fully Vetted
COMMENTS (22)
1
Bullfighting
by on 05/25/2010 08:24am

Even if the bull did win they would still have to put it down. From what I understand they cut the muscles in the bull's neck so that he can not lift it during the fight. Not to mention the swords the matador sticks in it during the fight. I feel nothing for this man who got gored. He deserves it as do the rest of his ilk.

2
More than just 1 victim
by on 05/25/2010 08:33am

I studied abroad in Spain for a year in college, and while I was there I was roped into attending a bullfight in the name of cultural emersion. The worst part for me was the middle when they brought in the mounted picadors. The horses in these shows are blindfolded as they are led by their riders towards an extremely hostile bull to aid in tormenting it. Several times during the fight I saw the horse actually get sandwiched between the wall and the bull and lifted off the ground by the bull's horns. The blindfolded horse has no idea where to go to get away from the pain and shock of these attacks, so he is forced by his rider to just stay put as he is mauled by the bull's horns. The Spaniards, who generally love their beautiful, muscular horses, are able to lie to themselves about how severely the horses are being harmed due to these protective capes called "petos," which I have read mostly serve to hide the wounds rather than protect the horse. Often horses used in bull fights have to be put down after the fight due to sustaining severe injuries.
The point is that bullfights don't only feature the torture of innocent bulls, but also the breach of trust between horse and rider that ends in terrible injuries for the horse. It is also worth noting that I completely regret attending the bullfight, not only for the obvious reasons but because the whole industry relies on tourist funding. Satisfying my own morbid curiosity wasn't worth supporting torture.

3
Organized torture
by on 05/25/2010 08:55am

It says a lot about the depths to which the human race can sink that there is an organized activity where large numbers of people gather to watch the organized torture of an animal. It's beyond my comprehension how this can be considered entertainment. It makes me wonder just how "civilized" 21st century human beings actually are that we tolerate the existence of this institution.

4
Thank you
by on 05/25/2010 09:00am

Thank you for writing this. I would love to go to Spain and see the architectual works of Gaudi but I will never set foot in the uncivilized animal abusing country that is Spain. And just thing- bull fighting is the more sanitized animal abuse there. Their other "cultural practices" regarding animals are even more horrific- beating goats to death, driving donkeys off cliffs, we just don't hear about them as much.

So ironic that this is the country that voted on giving citizenship to great apes.

God I hate Spain.

5
by on 05/25/2010 09:42am

A better alternative is the French-style course camarguaise. The bull doesn't get hurt (on purpose) and there is actual strategy involved. I don't know if it's exactly what the bull would choose to do on his own, but it's certainly no worse than what rodeo bulls undergo in the U.S.

I saw a course in the 2000-year-old Roman amphitheater in Arles and must admit I was completely transfixed. Here's a good-quality video of a different course in the same venue. (Absolutely no blood or gore, I swear!)

6
Thank You!
by on 05/25/2010 09:44am

This subject boggles the mind for any of us who feel compassion for our fellow sentient creatures. Thank you for taking the time and effort to put it out there for debate (what's to debate?!).

I was really disgusted with the information shared by donnadw! Horrific! But again, thank you for sharing, exposing these practices to those of us who did not know.

7
by on 05/25/2010 09:45am

Oh, and I meant to mention that just because the course camarguaise originates in France, that doesn't mean visitors there should assume that all bullfights will be that type. If it says corrida, it's the Spanish style and someone (human or taurine) will probably die.

8
Charles Bukowski
by on 05/25/2010 10:03am

"Watching the bull get the matador.

That's the best."

9
Dances with Bulls
by on 05/25/2010 10:21am

finnette, the weaponless bull "fighting" sports you cite are the inheritors of TRUE ancient tradition. Old, old, old.

They were ancient when this was painted:

http://www.marin.edu/~jim/photos/bullstuff/bulldancelg.jpg

Old, and essentially reverential, religious, anchored in mysteries that may be older than domestication. The bull cult is second only to bear worship in antiquity and universality.

Spanish-style wounded-bull-torture-as-tourist-spectacle is no more venerable -- or venerating of the victim -- than was the practice of butchers pitting dogs against bulls in order to "tenderize" the meat.

H. Houlahan

http://cynography.blogspot.com/

10
thank you for posting
by on 05/25/2010 02:00pm

thank you for posting the link I've been watching it over-and-over cheering for the bull!

11
I don't wish evil...
by on 05/25/2010 04:21pm

... on any human, But I daresay the wounding was fully justified.

I'm fairly certain there's nothing in any way redeeming in the activity called Bull "Fighting."

12
History of Animal Cruelty
by on 05/25/2010 04:24pm

I recommend a wonderful book on the history of animal cruelty:
For the love of animals : the rise of the animal protection movement by Kathryn Shevelow
New York : Henry Holt and Co., 2008

It helps to put in perspective how we get to be the way we are regarding our attitudes and beliefs about animal cruelty. And how Spain got to be the way it is. Bullfighting has a long legacy of cruelty that is sanctioned by Spanish society. It is not sport. It is not fair. Like boxing it appeals to base excitement in humans. I think anyone who is interested in the subject would benefit from knowing the philosophical underpinnings of our attitudes about animal cruelty...Cartesian philosophy that animals were machines without real feelings.

The summary from my library:
In eighteenth-century England--where cockfighting and bullbaiting drew large crowds, and the abuse of animals was routine--the idea of animal protection was dismissed as laughably radical. But as pets became more common, human attitudes toward animals evolved. An unconventional duchess defended their intellect in her writings; a gentleman scientist believed that animals should be treated with compassion; and with the concentrated efforts of an eccentric Scots barrister and a flamboyant Irishman, the lives of beasts--and, correspondingly, men and women--began to change. Kathryn Shevelow, a scholar of the eighteenth century, gives us the dramatic story of the bold reformers who braved attacks because they sympathized with the plight of creatures everywhere. More than just a history, this cultural narrative is an exploration into how our feelings toward animals reveal our ideas about ourselves, God, mercy, and nature.--From publisher description

13
breeders
by on 05/25/2010 07:36pm

I would like to know if anyone out there has purchased a Beagle puppy from Blackhawk Beagles Kennel? I did and she has a condition known as Patellar Luxation. Which is just a fancy way for saying dislocated kneecaps. This is a genetic condition. You can contact at my e-mail which is snickerzoe@aol.com. I would really appreciate any info I can get. Thank you. Rhonda Sidell.

14
Ancient Rome
by on 05/25/2010 08:18pm

Fighting animals in "fair" fights goes way back to the old days of the Colosseum. You'd think that with all we've learned and grown, we could certainly grow out of this. We have to find a way to fight all forms of animal abuse from bullfighting to cock fighting and dog fighting. Any ideas?

15
Ancient Rome
by on 05/25/2010 08:20pm

Fighting animals in "fair" fights goes way back to the old days of the Colosseum. You'd think that with all we've learned and grown, we could certainly grow out of this. We have to find a way to fight all forms of animal abuse from bullfighting to cock fighting and dog fighting. Any ideas?

16
Bull fighting
by on 05/25/2010 08:54pm

I agree with you 100% that bull fighting is beyond cruel and inhumane. I just wanted to share another "underdog victory" story. I live on a small 5 1/2 acre parcel in Michigan. There are many hawks in the area. A couple of weeks ago, to my dismay, I saw a hawk grab a squirrel. But the squirrel was gutsy. It bent up and bit the hawk's leg, forcing it to drop the squirrel, which got away. SCORE ONE FOR THE SQUIRREL!

17
I'm for the bull...
by on 05/25/2010 10:24pm

Great article, Doc! No matter how they candy-coat it, bullfighting is yet another disgusting blood sport put on to entertain the ignorant masses! When will the human race ever become civilized?!

18
Slightly OT
by on 05/25/2010 10:48pm

horses and cats:
I think it's more than a little odd to mention a hawk performing a natural and necessary behavior in hunting a squirrel in the same vein as bullfighting. Predation is not cruelty, it is nature and is necessary not only for the hawks but also for the health of the squirrel population. Bullfighting is inhumane, unnecessary for either participating party, rigged, unfair, and essentially cruelty and torture for nothing but entertainment. As someone who has worked for years with both hawks and squirrels, I know what it's like to root for one or the other at times, but in the end the squirrel getting away just spells death anyway - either for the hawk or for the next animal it gets. Comparing it to sanctioned animal torture is inaccurate and not only blows the squirrel's predicament far out of proportion but in my mind does not afford proper outrage to bullfighting.

19
toro
by on 05/26/2010 10:52am

The corrida is like a High Mass in the Roman Catholic church ... a spectical that includes consuming the body and blood of Christ.

It's not a sport ... it's a tragedy.

20
Bull Murdering
by on 05/27/2010 04:41pm

Yep! Score one for the bull! I have been rooting for the bulls for years - about 60 years actually!
Why is it that the Latinos have such a bloodlust? Welcome to the 21st Century, Spain and Mexico - It is time to fight for animal rights.

21
High Mass
by on 05/28/2010 07:56pm

No one is tortured or killed in High Mass. Even the Roman Catholic Church is beyond that.

22
Bull fighting
by on 05/30/2010 10:28am

As a Brit animal lover (and protector) having lived in Spain for almost 20 years I have made myself unpopular with the Spaniards by cheering when on the odd occasion, the bull wins (??) I have one simple argument. The bull didn't choose to be there, the Matador and his cronies did, for the glory and the money so if they get hurt or killed that is their own fault, and I have not the slightest sympathy for them.
Ian@spainanimalhub.org Spain animal protectors

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.


About fully vetted

Patty Khuly, VMD, MBA

Photo of Dr Khuly

Dr. Khuly is a former petMD blogger and small animal veterinarian in Miami, Florida, where she practices medicine at Sunset Animal Clinic and serves on the board of the South Florida Veterinary Medical Association. She is a graduate of Wellesley College, the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and The Wharton School of Business.

As a significant sideline, she writes...a lot. She authors pet health columns for USA Today, The Miami Herald and Vetstreet. She also writes a popular monthly column for Veterinary Practice News and serves as regular contributor to Veterinary Economics, The Bark, and the Veterinary News Network.

Dr. Khuly lives in South Miami with her brood of hens, goats, dogs, cats...and humans.

Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Check Your Pet Food Bags!
The recall of pet foods manufactured at a Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, S.C....
READ MORE
No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Any Dog Can Bite
May 20-26 is National Dog Bite Prevention Week. Being bitten is just one of the...
READ MORE
A New Link Between Pet and Human Health
A study appearing in the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases points to a new link...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Does Horse Racing Deserve Your Support?
I breathed a big sigh of relief on the evening of Saturday, May 5. The 138th running...
READ MORE
Maggots: Thumbs Up or Down?
The weather is starting to heat up here in Colorado, which means that any day...
READ MORE
Palliative Care ≠ Murder
I talked yesterday about compassion fatigue, which often develops when caregivers...
READ MORE
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2012 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved
x
Stay informed about your pet's health...and more!