Subscribe to
Fully Vetted
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

 

Studying Moose Arthritis (Really!), and What it Might Mean for People and Pet Nutrition

August 20, 2010 / (8) comments


There’s a new study out on moose arthritis and nutrition. Researchers from Michigan have discovered a window into the potential connection between moose and other species when it comes to degenerative joint disease.

Turns out, poorly nourished moose seem to be be suffering increased rates of arthritis. Interesting, right?

It may sound like an odd, arcane thing to study — moose nutrition isn’t exactly a hotbed of academic interest — but somehow, I find that this is the kind of research that rocks my world!

After all, animals are excellent sentinels for all kinds of disease conditions. This, I internalized in my fourth year of veterinary school during an epidemiology rotation at the CDC (in which some cancers and respiratory diseases were first ID’d in pets before their nearby human counterparts). So is it any wonder that I gravitate to this vein of study?

So it was that when this article from Tuesday’s New York Times landed in my inbox, I knew I’d be addressing it in short order. Here’s an excerpt with the lowdown:


In the 100 years since the first moose swam into Lake Superior and set up shop on an island, they have mostly minded their moosely business, munching balsam fir and trying to evade hungry gray wolves.

But now the moose of Isle Royale have something to say — well, their bones do. Many of the moose, it turns out, have arthritis. And scientists believe their condition’s origin can help explain human osteoarthritis — by far the most common type of arthritis, affecting one of every seven adults 25 and older and becoming increasingly prevalent.

The arthritic Bullwinkles got that way because of poor nutrition early in life, an extraordinary 50-year research project has discovered. That could mean, scientists say, that some people’s arthritis can be linked in part to nutritional deficits, in the womb and possibly throughout childhood.


Now, to my veterinary way of seeing things, moose, humans, and our pets are pretty darn similar in how we/they respond orthopedically/developmentally to environmental manipulation. It stands to reason that moose whose sub-par nutrition has led to arthritis offer interesting clues into veterinary nutrition. In light of this kind of research, it’s a no-brainer that how we feed ourselves and our pets — especially early on — almost certainly affects our/their long-term comfort and orthopedic longevity. Again, from the Times:


Osteoarthritis’s exact cause remains unknown, but it is generally thought to stem from aging and wear and tear on joints, exacerbated for some by genes. Overweight or obese people have a greater arthritis risk, usually attributed to the load their joints carry, and the number of cases is increasing as people live longer and weigh more.

But the moose work, along with some human research, suggests that the origins of arthritis are more complex, probably influenced by early exposures to nutrients and other factors while our bodies are developing. Even obesity’s link to arthritis probably goes beyond extra pounds, experts say, to include the impact on the body of eating the wrong things.

Nutrients, experts say, might influence composition or shape of bones, joints or cartilage. Nutrition might also affect hormones, the likelihood of later inflammation or oxidative stress, even how a genetic predisposition for arthritis is expressed or suppressed.


Human and animal studies, the Times article goes on to explain, have already determined that early nutrition — in tandem with genetic predispositions — influence ideal bone and joint developement. For example:

  • Low infant birth weight in the U.K. has been linked to arthritis in men’s hands
  • Chinese adults who were in-utero during the great famine had disproportionately high rates of disability
  • An orthopedist at Cornell's College of Veterinary Medicine reports that even too much food is detrimental, as overfed pregnant mares’ babies suffered more "abnormal joint and tendon development from excessive nutrition"
  • Overfeeding has been tied to joint trouble in humans in more ways than just having excess pounds to lug around


Like the others, this study offers no smoking guns on causation, merely an additional insight into the degree to which environmental factors like nutrition undoubtedly corellate with the kind of joint pathology so common to humans and our pets.

The article’s ultimate conclusion is that "much is unknown about nutrition’s relevance," which leaves us all in the same kind of lurch we started in.

Still, can you blame me for assuming that this study recommends the obvious: to urge my clients to feed their pets the most balanced/varied/high quality diet possible — especially early on in life?

Sigh … if we only knew what that was.



Dr. Patty Khuly

 



Pic of the day:  "moose eats cat brain" by kennakenai

Subscribe to Fully Vetted
COMMENTS (8)
1
Love this Post!
by PamelaJ on 08/20/2010 08:41am

In my family, we've been interested in nutrition for many generations. We've seen the difference good nutrition can make in people -- and in more recent years, our dogs. THANK YOU for bringing this important topic to the forefront!

2
Good-one
by kay morris on 08/20/2010 10:10am

My Grandmother always said, you are what you eat.

3
Moose Arthritis
by Canine Mom on 08/20/2010 10:40am

I am like you, I tend to gravitate to the "data" about such things that we already know, and are just looking for the facts to back it up.

In my family arthritis is an ailment that is progressively being phased out and we think it's from, as you believe, our diets and getting enough exercise. I also agree that it is the same for our beloved pets.

When I quit smoking last year and realized that WE had gained weight, WE began spending a LOT of spare time in the parks just walking and it really has helped my hips, which it were I am cursed, lol. WE did lose our weight so all is well.

Thank you for your newsletters, I enjoy them AND have the added benefit of learning something almost every time I read.

Shafiah

4
How painful
by ktorre87 on 08/20/2010 06:32pm

Being what my family calls a bleeding heart animal lover, the main thought I had while reading this was "Poor arthritic Moose!" I mean, it's such a painful disease, and how do you treat a wild animal for something like that? No one does. Sad stuff.
Any ways, speaking of nutrition, I a in contact with an organisation that rescues cats and dogs and spays and neuters them if need be. They rescued a small dog who was in severe need of a hair cut and nail trim. I am not sure sure of his age but I think he was on the older side. Anyways they put him under for some dental work and his jaw shattered because he had very severe jaw rot. They had to euthanize him. Why? Because his diet had consisted of Old Roy dog food and table scraps. I have heard negative things in the past about this brand but this is the worst. Good nutrition is very impotant to bones. RIP Timmy.

5
by Akita6 on 08/21/2010 10:50am

Just signed on.
It is heartwarming to read that Dr. Khuly champions for subjects
with little information that could help our pups.
-Stan

6
Painful..but not for long
by Dr. Patty Khuly on 08/22/2010 09:12am

"Being what my family calls a bleeding heart animal lover, the main thought I had while reading this was "Poor arthritic Moose!" I mean, it's such a painful disease, and how do you treat a wild animal for something like that? No one does. Sad stuff."

The reality is that at the very first manifestation of the disease, these moose are dead. They don't have the luxury of suffering with it for very long with all those predators about. Somehow, that makes me feel much better about the course of this disease. There are plenty of crueler conditions out there.

7
What to feed
by Dog Mama on 08/23/2010 01:13am

Yes, what is the most balanced/varied/high quality diet possible... sigh

Somehow I do feel that commercial kibble might not be it though. At least not the major brands.

One would think that with all our science and brain power we would have at least figured out what to eat and what to feed our pets ...

8
by cesg on 09/07/2010 05:11pm

how interesting!! thank you for sharing

LEAVE COMMENTS

Please login or sign up to leave comments.


About fully vetted

Patty Khuly, VMD, MBA

Photo of Dr Khuly

Dr. Khuly is a former petMD blogger and small animal veterinarian in Miami, Florida, where she practices medicine at Sunset Animal Clinic and serves on the board of the South Florida Veterinary Medical Association. She is a graduate of Wellesley College, the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and The Wharton School of Business.

As a significant sideline, she writes...a lot. She authors pet health columns for USA Today, The Miami Herald and Vetstreet. She also writes a popular monthly column for Veterinary Practice News and serves as regular contributor to Veterinary Economics, The Bark, and the Veterinary News Network.

Dr. Khuly lives in South Miami with her brood of hens, goats, dogs, cats...and humans.

Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Dangers Associated with Novel Ingredient ...
Have you noticed the recent proliferation of over-the-counter pet foods that contain...
READ MORE
The Cost of Care
My daughter recently had her five year old checkup and it was a doozy –...
READ MORE
Horse Slaughter – Coming Back to a Town ...
In 2007, the last plant that slaughtered horses for human consumption within the...
READ MORE
A Case of the Giggles
I think I may have made a mistake when I picked my career. Don’t get me...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

Horse Slaughter – Coming Back to a Town ...
In 2007, the last plant that slaughtered horses for human consumption within the...
READ MORE
The Cost of Care
My daughter recently had her five year old checkup and it was a doozy –...
READ MORE
Vet-Speak
I’ve heard that one of the most useful parts of my book,
READ MORE
A Case of the Giggles
I think I may have made a mistake when I picked my career. Don’t get me...
READ MORE

PETMD POLL

What would your pet do if it had opposable thumbs?

 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2012 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved
x
Stay informed about your pet's health...and more!