Subscribe to
Fully Vetted
Dr. Coates is a veterinarian based in the other “Sunshine State” – that's Colorado to the rest of you – where she lives and plays with a varied range of animals. She shares her professional and personal experiences, Monday through Friday, here on petMD's blog, the Fully Vetted. Log in for your daily dose of her insight and wisdom.

 

A rose by any other name...but 'Slumdog'??

August 15, 2009 / (31) comments


It’s been two months and I’m still catching heat over my scraggly stray’s name choice.

After this puppymill Pug arrived, amid a flurry of demodectic mange and fleas, my son had promptly christened him “Billy.” In the way only an eleven year-old who sees no evil growing on skin can do, he took one look and uttered the two mundane syllables.

But they didn’t stick. Between the deformed limbs, the bulbously deviated eyes, the strange, collapsed feet and his flourishing parasitism, “Billy” was not meant to be. After a few days of this child-enforced, farce of a name game, the true name was uttered quite by accident. This time there was no disputing it: he was a quintessential slumdog. So “Slumdog” it is and will forever be.

The moral of the story? Never let a child name a family pet. Not unless he’s willing to take on the dirty work, too.

Yet there’s more to this story than how one pet came to bear his true name and the cautions that inevitably attend childhood impulsiveness. It’s to do with how we make lifelong decisions that affect how we bond to our pets.

I mean, does a name like Slumdog mean I’ll never take him seriously? That he won’t be as much a member of the family as a Sophie Sue or a Vincent? That he’ll get away with silly behavior based on his ridiculous name?

After all, every one of my pets before Slumdog has borne a human-style name...not an epithet used to describe a low-caste citizen of Mumbai. Even my chickens are named after the mythological Harpies and Furies.

But does what’s in a name really matter? Or does it all ultimately come down to the same thing once the name is just a name and the personality–– the true soul of the animal––is revealed over time? I wonder.

 

Subscribe to Fully Vetted
COMMENTS (31)
1
by on 08/22/2009 03:09pm

Well, my newest addition I named Spur. I always wanted a dog named Spur and all my other dogs came named. I love the "Man From Snowy River" movie where Kirk Douglas plays a double character. The mountain man he played was Spur and I always thought that would make a great dog name. OK, it IS a great dog name, but I forgot to consider all the little nicknames that go with it. Most often he is The Spurminator, but Spurmie was a favorite when he was younger. The Spurmiester, The Spurito, all OK......but, SPURMIE????? The SPURMINATOR?????

2
by on 08/20/2009 12:44pm

I've heard worse names. In fact, years ago there was a reoccuring bit in the local paper about things people had named their pets. Worst one was probably "Fekus" (spelled F-e-c-e-s).

3
by on 08/20/2009 07:38am

As long as you're happy and not upsetting anyone, go with any name that suits. I don't believe it will have any impact at all on how much of a member of the family he is. Anyway, they might have 'real' names but they end up being called anything and everything. (Which is how Snaffle is commonly referred to as 'Mr. Johnson' and Casper as 'Captain Stompy').

4
by on 08/17/2009 12:54pm

We are really not much good at names here.  Current cats are Ricky, who had that name when we got him but who goes by Rickus (the Kittus), Wikie, Wikiewikie, Marshmallow and others less printable, and Fuzzy.  Fuzzy is fuzzy.  We weren't really planning to keep her.

5
by on 08/17/2009 10:48am

I forgot to mention the internet problems...  The most frequent problem occurring lately is that water gets between the keyboard and the chair...  ;-)

6
by on 08/17/2009 10:32am

I think most animals respond to names the way we do:


They learn to respond to whatever name you call when you call them to dinner, and don't change it unless they are waiting for the statute of limitations to expire somewhere.


Rock - Rutherford


Goats - Larry, Moe and Curly with room for a Shep


Chickens - Pepper, Paprika, Ginger


Dogs - Corkey, Roscoe, Shadrah, Mishah


Hamster - Concord (New Hamster)


Cats - Chloe, Cali


I had a friend whose dog got out so often the neighbors complained about him calling for him, so he changed the dog's name to "Taxi" thinking that fewer people would complain about him calling for one.


My wife didn't let me name any of our four children.


I had suggested Eugene as a tribute to John Denver since in the "Baby Book of Names" Eugene was aplhabetically "Almost Evan"


I wanted to name the last child Soon Lee since I had heard that every fourth child born in the world is Chinese.

7
by on 08/17/2009 01:53am

Well, that didn't work!  Let's try this: Baby.  Trying to figure out "what" she is.  I said "Lab" and "Lab Mix" showed up on her vet file :)  Doesn't really matter to me but I'm always curious as to "what's in there".

8
by on 08/17/2009 01:45am

It's fun to read that others have stories similar to mine but here's one I don't admit to often.  My son, about 8 at the time, named his cat "General Dammit", mostly 'cause he wanted to be able to say "dammit" without getting in trouble.  He called him "Dammit" and he'd never come; I'd call for "General" and he'd appear on my lap or at my feet.  Wasn't long before he was just "General" although we left the "official" name stand.


How long can a 60 pound dog keep eating 12 cups/day of food?  LOL, Well, her poop is nearly normal and at least her ribs are fading from view.  She may have worms but, otherwise, she's seems to be in pretty good shape.  Survival genes?  Starting to hunt a name for her since "Baby's" suitability is fading fast and need a decent name for the adoption process.  Resisting tagging her with "Evil Eye" for the way she's still eyeing the neighbor's cats and hens...


"Baby"

9
by on 08/16/2009 11:41pm

We are extremely careful about names around here.  After ending up with a Golden Retriever named Molson (thank you to my ex!) each pet name after that has been thoroughly considered.


I swore never to have a lame name pet again.


Slumdog certainly does not classify as lame, and frankly I think you should be able to name your pet whatever you please, but it is worth considering the feeling that the name will evoke in others.


I facebooked an article out of New Zealand recently (I think that was the location) about a blind man who had been chastised numerous times for beating the crap out of his "guide dog", a handsome ACD, in public pretty much daily.  The dog's name said it all.  A$$hole.


I think about how I felt when I heard that name, and the feelings I would have had towards someone I didn't know who chose to name their pet something so vulgar.  


While Slumdog is certainly not vulgar, and perhaps even a bit endearing, I don't think that the heat you're catching will go away any time soon.  It's just the gut reaction one gets to such a name.


Particularly if said person is aware of your previous name choices - Vincent and Sophie Sue are both sweet, charming and even regal sounding.  


In our house we've named hundreds of animals - our own and rescues - and each also earned a nickname.  We currently have Lexus, Fable, Juno, Pey'j, Jasper, Kenya and Kirby.  We once had a Pom named Gretchen, which attracted some odd comments, but the name just fit.

10
by on 08/16/2009 10:04pm

Oh boy, Mushroom & Dufus sound better! He is a "dwarf" dog (pick one of the 7) with a "fiddle" front, that has been given a second "chance", and is surely a devoted "lovebug"!

11
by on 08/16/2009 07:38pm

After I read Barbara's story about placing rescues in new homes, it reminded me of an unwanted German Shorthair that came my way.  He was the most lovable, goofy dog but I couldn't keep him because he kept trying to get to my cats.  So I contacted the rescue for German Shorthairs and they told me they would put his picture on their website but they would call him Duke instead of what I had named him which was Dufus.  I eventually received a call from a guy who was interested and right off I told him that his name wasn't Duke but it was Dufus.  He started laughing because he and his wife were looking for a companion for their female German Shorthair and her name was Doosie.  So Dufus and Doosie ended up together, happily ever after.

12
by on 08/16/2009 07:14pm

I think Slumdog is a hilarious name, but as I have a pit bull named Mushroom, I'm not sure how much my opinion counts ;)


I will admit that I have a hard time taking him as seriously as the other two dogs, but I don't think that has as much to do with his name as it does with his "Class clown" personality. He's not a serious dog. I did, when I got him, try to change his name, but nothing fit as well as Mushroom, and so it stayed. I have no idea who named him (somebody in rescue), but it makes me smile. His AKC ILP name (for our failed stint in Rally Obedience) is Siren's Shiitake Happens. A more aptly named dog there never has been. And he is certainly no less a member of my family than the other dogs. And no less loved for having a dumb name.

13
by on 08/16/2009 11:30am

My cats all have human names, and I do call them by those names, but rarely. They each have other names that they answer to and I have no idea how I ended up with them:


George is usually Sweet Pea

Templeton is Monster or Booger, and occasionally Temtem.


Waldo is Chicken or Chicken Lickin.


Murray is Fat Man


Oddly enough, Angel, the dog, who came with her name, only gets called Angel.  Dunno why.


Some friends of my boyfriend's named their cat "Little F*cker".  Seriously.  I have to admit I felt a little sorry for the cat when I first met it.

14
by on 08/16/2009 10:27am

We wanted to name a dog Emily. When we got her, though, it was evident she was really an Emma Lee. And of course we don't usually call her that. She's The Princess, Wumple, Wumplebutt, Emmaroo...etc. Clark was named Clarky from a previous home, so we kept Clark but usually he's LittleEars, Muppett, or FlufferNutless. (I know that one's kind of mean, but he's fluffy, and neutered, so...I was thinking Fluffernutter sandwich at the time. Kamala is usually Mali (said molly), or Kami, but also often Stripey Dog or Tiger Dog. And lastly we have a dog that at first we called Mangy Mutt (thought he had mange tho the skin scrape said no, found him that way) and I just finally said there was no way we could call him that in public, so since he LOVES bananas, he's now Nanners and now normally Nay, or Old Man.


It's kind of like how some dogs have their AKC names, but then their call names. Mine have their "legal" names and then they have the names they *actually* answer to.

15
by on 08/16/2009 08:27am

I think a dog doesn't much care, although cats just might.  I once met a cat out in the neighborhood who walked up and he just seemed to be introducing himself as Gus.  When I found out where he lived, I was amused that they said they couldn't understand why 'Fluffy' wouldn't stay in the house.  I told them he seemed to be much more of a Gus to me, but they didn't get the subtle hint.


I do think that other people may judge you by what you name yor pets, though.  I recently met a girl and her mother and an adorable puppy.  When they said the puppy had been named by the girl's boyfriend, I couldn't help thinking that the mother needed to do whatever it took to get her daughter as far away from him as possible, because he is, IMO, a giant jackass (and worse).  He'd insisted the puppy be named 'Choaz' as in 'get cho az ova heer.' 

16
by on 08/16/2009 05:34am

I always tell my vet when I take a new pet in...don't put the name in stone yet, as pets tend to share their "true" name only after they have lived with you for a while.


Licorice is actually "boo boo"


gingersnap is actually "ooba doggie"


the list goes on...sometimes it is a personality thing, sometimes it's a name they respond too... I have a male cat named petunia...and he answers to it..


I believe pets have true names. They don't have to be muffy, fluffy, beauty and duke....


Give Slumdog a pet for me :)


 


 

17
by on 08/16/2009 01:03am

What is endearing to one may not be to another but to bad. They don't live with the dog nor know the history between them and their owner. (or know the history of why the name was chosen which is a huge part of it)


When my cousin was young she thought her name was Turkey Turd because of an incident involving bird poop. (and she would only answer to that for a time which looked very odd the day she went missing and they had to yell the nickname in public before they found her) Did that mean her father, who dubbed her with the unfortunate nickname, loved her any less? That is absurd. To HIM it was an endearment, that is what matters.


Look beyond the name to the care the person gives their dog, the tone in which they speak to the dog, and the way they touch their dog. That speaks far more volumes to me than the name they chose. It is only us who have the hangup about their names, not the dog. To them actions mean everything, not the words.


Tail wags.


 

18
by on 08/15/2009 07:40pm

Speaking of children naming pets... A neighbor of mine has three white cats, and their five-year-old daughter named them. They're called... Snow, Snowflake, and Snowball.

19
by on 08/15/2009 07:38pm

Barb, Don't know about where you are but, around here, the internet seems to be acting squirrelly the last few days; sometimes fine and other times having real fits and doing odd things.  Thought it was my new connection but I'm hearing about it from others who are 60 miles away at my old condos.  I'm getting fairly persistent error messages when I try to run spell check here.

20
by on 08/15/2009 06:50pm

Linda H: I messed up taking a bigger block on my post, too. Not sure how that happens! Your Eli is one handsome dude too! The Sealyham is Ms. PiccaLilli or PL for short & lovingly adored by her owners. She gives meaning to the "ham" by being the all-posing "diva" since birth.


I'm glad you mentioned lots of names & sources, I have "fingers & paws crossed here" for a nifty nice name for Slumdog.

21
by on 08/15/2009 06:35pm

Sorry for the awkward link in my previous post. I can't figure out how some of you are able to inset links - the icon for doing so is grayed out for me.


Barbara, your Sealy is adorable. Great photo. Here is my Eli, when he was shaggy last winter.


Eli

22
by on 08/15/2009 06:15pm

When I am expecting a new puppy I start making lists of names, but I don't actually select the name until he or she arrives. Sometimes the name comes quickly, sometimes I try out half a dozen before one sticks. Interestingly enough, it has never been the name at the top of the list before the puppy arrived. Sometimes the name isn't even on the list.


Henry got his name the fastest. The day he arrived, all of nine weeks old, my neighbors and I were playing with him in the front yard. We just looked at him and said, "he's a Henry." It seemed to fit him perfectly for his whole life - nobility and goofiness.


Eli arrived at six months. I was co-owning him with his breeder, who is a big sports fan and called him Shaq after Shaquille O'Neal. After about a week I called her said, "you can call him Shaq, but I just can't." And a good thing too, since he is just a little guy, for an Airedale, barely 22 inches, but big in spirit and joie de vivre. Eli is the name that stuck.


Tulsa took a long time to name. Nothing seemed to stick. I had a friend who had a Pharaoh Hound named Memphis, doubly appropriate since Memphis is an Egyptian name and the puppy came from Memphis, Tennessee. My puppy was from Oklahoma so I tried calling her Tulsa - and she did have a sort of cowgirl swagger.


Lola arrived with the name, and though I wasn't quite sure it was the right name at first, nothing else stuck. I don't usually worry about making a connection between a dog's registered name and call name, but I registered her as "Laughing Out Loud" and thinking of LOLa as representing the way she makes me laugh made the name work.


Before the Airedales I had Malamutes. The first one was name Kaleb, which means dog, plus in Tolkein Elvish 'celeb' means silver, and since I am a Hobbit (my last name) and he was a beautiful silver color, it worked on multiple levels. He was registered as "The Thundering Herd" which was a nickname he earned as a puppy.


Petra was registered as Stormy Petrel, an antarctic seabird, but petra means rock, which fit her dense head well.


As for other species, I once has a pet Grasshopper Mouse, the only known carnivorous mouse, maybe the only carnivorous rodent. It is a solitary animal, and howls to maintain its territory, standing like a tiny wolf on an elevated spot, holding up one paw and throwing it's head back. Because of its small size, the howl sounds something like a teakettle. I named him Fenwick, for the Duchy of Grand Fenwick in The Mouse that Roared, <a target="_blank" href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mouse_That_Roared" target="blank">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Mouse_That_Roared</a>


And I once had a hamster named Uncle George Aloysius Hamster. I was young then, but it seemed to fit.


Linda H


Buy a chance to win the gorgeous 'Fairy Tails' quilt and help Airedales in need. Check often for special drawings or just enjoy looking at <a target="_blank" href="http://www.airedalequilt.org/" target-"blank">http://www.airedalequilt.org/</a>.


 

23
by on 08/15/2009 06:08pm

Please, please reconsider??! I look at that picture and think he is so deserving of an endearing name. Surely your son has some favorite words or terms that signify more than "slum" that would be suitable?


It isn't because it will make him loved more or treated differently, but simply the public perception of a name. I placed many "rescues" and 90% of the adoptive homes changed their names to something they liked and possibly to signify a fresh start.


I agree it doesn't have to be a human name, lot's of inanimate object words make good names.


When I placed my Sealyham's sibling, we dubbed "Pickles", the new owner was greatly concerned why we chose it. And insisted on knowing just exactly what kind of pickle was she? A sour, a dill, or what? The truth be told, Pickles was the image & personality of her grammie and sometimes sweet and sometimes naughty with an expression of haughty---she was a bread & butter pickle! Now aptly named "PiccaLilli"


pl


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


 


web site---My Photos link

24
by on 08/15/2009 05:24pm

I think Slumdog is endearing and will always be a reminder that he's special and has some special needs. I like a name for a critter that suits them. My current brood includes Lady Bryde, Queen Sheba, Spooky Cat (called Pooky or THE baby), Tigger, and Princess. Princess' brother and protector, Bubba, died last year. And now my foundling called "Baby" until she's well enough to show who she really is. Before we started having children's birth certificates completed at hospitals, children weren't generally named until christening or some other ceremony for a number of reasons, including giving them time to show their personalities so an appropriate name could be chosen.

25
by on 08/15/2009 05:08pm

I've given my dogs "human" names and eventually their true personalities toldl me what their real dog names were. My Courtney bichon comes to the loving name of CooCoo Ka Choo.  Shaina Shih Tzu, comes (or not) to ShayShay or Sh*tHead.  They still know I'm the alpha and that's all that counts besides their happiness.

26
by on 08/15/2009 03:08pm

Their true soul is definitely revealed over time, regardless of the name. We were recently fortunate to have the German Shepherd Rescue of Northern California help save a neglected 8 month old puppy from owners who wanted to put him down after they left him tangled up with a rope in their Oakland backyard. The vet recommended amputation. They didn't want a three legged Shepherd. A compassionate tech took him in and told GSRNC who immediately though of us.


They renamed him from "Chopper" to Wyatt Ray Dawg in memory of our dear Jerry G. Dawg who we lost to cancer 10 months ago. Coincidentally we have just found our perfect property, and Wyatt is now loving life with us in the mountains. He will continue to travel with us when we head south for the winters, and with his new name, he has big paws to fill ... Jerry's legacy – to support tripawds everywhere, by proving it is better to hop on three legs than to limp on four!

27
by on 08/15/2009 02:26pm

Only downside that I can see is that other people might judge your dog by his name and not see him for the shining soul that he is. 


Old Pup's name went the other way.  Her official name is Sweet Potato, but we now joke that we should truly have named her Wasabi, after the spicy horseradish paste.  No matter.  She's hardly called either of those things, but is usually Old Pup, Puparoon, Porkie Pie, Babydog, etc.

28
by on 08/15/2009 02:22pm

Oh, good grief.


As long as "Slumdog" is well-meaning, not denigrating, there's no reason for it to be anything besides a collection of syllables that the dog recognizes.  If you spat it out like an insult every time you said it, sure, that would be unpleasant.  But just to use it as the sound to which the dog responds?  No big deal.

29
by on 08/15/2009 01:32pm

I have a client with a lovely small dog who has the unfortunate moniker "Sh@tty"  He is super sweet, and his owners adore him...he started out with something more respectable, but he accidentally ended up as he is.  I can't bring myself to call him that in front of anyone, though my front desk staff seems to enjoy it.

30
by on 08/15/2009 01:21pm

As long as the critter is loved and taken care of, it could care less what its name is.  So why should we care what another person names their critters?  It has meaning to them and that is all that matters.

31
by on 08/15/2009 12:57pm

I don't think the name matters once you've gotten to know the animal's personality.  We always gave our dogs human names while I was growing up, but my parents' latest dog was named after a Disney character with a non-human name.  At first my mom hated the name (she didn't pick it), but after two years, the name doesn't matter.  It hasn't affected her ability to bond with the dog.  It doesn't influence how she views the dog's behavior.  Those things are affected by the dog's personality.  Besides, the dog's personality and behavior fit better with her non-human name than with a more mundane name.

LEAVE COMMENTS

Connect with Facebook or login to leave comments.


About fully vetted

Patty Khuly, VMD, MBA

Photo of Dr Khuly

Dr. Khuly is a former petMD blogger and small animal veterinarian in Miami, Florida, where she practices medicine at Sunset Animal Clinic and serves on the board of the South Florida Veterinary Medical Association. She is a graduate of Wellesley College, the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and The Wharton School of Business.

As a significant sideline, she writes...a lot. She authors pet health columns for USA Today, The Miami Herald and Vetstreet. She also writes a popular monthly column for Veterinary Practice News and serves as regular contributor to Veterinary Economics, The Bark, and the Veterinary News Network.

Dr. Khuly lives in South Miami with her brood of hens, goats, dogs, cats...and humans.

Subscribe to Fully Vetted

Most Read Fully Vetted Articles

Check Your Pet Food Bags!
The recall of pet foods manufactured at a Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, S.C....
READ MORE
No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Any Dog Can Bite
May 20-26 is National Dog Bite Prevention Week. Being bitten is just one of the...
READ MORE
A New Link Between Pet and Human Health
A study appearing in the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases points to a new link...
READ MORE

Most Commented Articles

No Excuse for Skipping Rabies Vaccination
The Carlsbad, New Mexico area just suffered through one of the worst rabies outbreaks...
READ MORE
Does Horse Racing Deserve Your Support?
I breathed a big sigh of relief on the evening of Saturday, May 5. The 138th running...
READ MORE
Maggots: Thumbs Up or Down?
The weather is starting to heat up here in Colorado, which means that any day...
READ MORE
Palliative Care ≠ Murder
I talked yesterday about compassion fatigue, which often develops when caregivers...
READ MORE
 
MORE FROM PETMD.COM
©1999-2012 petMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved
x
Stay informed about your pet's health...and more!