Why Do We Diss Cats In Favor of Dogs?

JAN 26, 2010

Did you know that despite the fact that cats rank as the number one pet in the US (population-wise, anyway), most companion animal veterinary spending happens in the canine arena. What's up with that?


Based on feline history, things should be way different. After all, cats were the revered species of an entire civilization (Egypt). One cat was the pampered pet of Muhammed. Literary figures like T.S. Eliot were awash in them. Nonetheless, the reality of their renowned independence, scavenger ways and cheap-to-keep lore submerges them well below dog status — even in North America where they get the best care … if you count the dollars, that is.

Even so, U.S. cat owners spend less than half of what dog owners do on their beloved pets: Cats get cheaper food, fewer toys, are far less likely to wear fine collars, get almost no grooming, suffer less frequent and less appropriate healthcare, and (as I wrote a few posts ago) they often survive outdoors under squalid and largely unsafe conditions.

As a vet I see it every day. Cat owners are generally less aggressive about seeking healthcare for their charges, and when they do, they balk at the estimates with greater alacrity than dog owners do.

Here are some questions to ponder: Is it that cats are less obviously companionable than dogs? Less likely to engender feelings of empathy? Are they just plain harder to get close to? Is it that they do so much on their own that it seems they need us humans so much less? Perhaps there are so many cats living in our midst that those who truly care shoulder the burden of many and have less to spend on each one? Or does their ubiquity decrease their value by way of the law of supply and demand?

The answer: All of the above.

To the point, you may have read this brief satire on dogs vs. cats. It goes something like this:

Diary of a dog: Happy happy happy. Ball ball ball. Food food food. Here he is again, the king of my world! Happy happy happy…

Diary of a cat: Day 281. My captors continue to torment me with dangling objects. I hack up a furball hoping to disgust them sufficiently to gain my release…

It’s hilarious because it’s so true … up to a point.

Our cats seem so different from humans that we tend to believe they require less of us. This translates into minimal research into cat diseases (a mere fraction of what goes to our dogs), fewer feline approved medications (e.g., only one pill for pain in cats compared to about twelve for dogs), and far fewer trips to the vet.

How about leash laws and mandatory rabies tagging? Nope. They don’t get the benefit of those, either. Unprovoked dogs bite more often, sure, but who’s likelier to interact with wildlife and contract rabies? One guess.

The ironies are endless, right?

 

 

 

 

 

Dr. Patty Khuly

Previous
Next
10 COMMENTS
1
by Lynne Katsikas on 01/26/2010 06:42am

It is a completw falacy that cats have less emotions for humans than dogs. A cat chooses a person to love, admitedly generally the person who feeds but not always. Two of my friends cats love me more and can hardly wait for me to visit. One of my cats hates all people other than me and will bite anybody who attampts to touch her. Take a dog on the other hand a friendly dog, approachable to all with wagging tail. Many people treat cats as a piece of furniture and do not communicate with the cat. Dogs by necessity require walking, i.e. human interaction. Believe me, I know cats very well. They talk and communicate if the owner is prepared to listen and respond. Cats are far more individual than dogs and I know dogs too. There is too much predudice against cats.

2
Cat caregiver
by delores lee on 01/26/2010 07:28am

I read with interest your reasoning of why dogs get more medical care than cats. As the caregiver of my own 13 cats (all altered), the numerous strays that I feed on a daily basis, and the cats and kittens I foster on a regularly, I cannot afford vet care on a regular basis. I live on a limited income and do the best I can for them. I figure anything I can do to give them a better quality of life is better than just turning my back and pampering just one. I just spent $250 Saturday getting a stray patched up from a dog attack, $50 yesterday at the SPCA getting a rescue spayed. Don't make me feel guilty for not giving the best - I'm doing the best I can. I do enjoy your daily blogs. Keep them coming!!

3
Diss Cats?
by Michael Sodos on 01/26/2010 10:45am

Not me! I have 2 dogs, 2 ferrets and 4 cats.
The dogs sleep downstairs and the cats sleep with/on me.

4
my cat
by wjoy1234 on 01/26/2010 12:22pm

I HAVE BLACK CAT LIKE TO SLEEP AT ARE BEDROOM DOOR AND AT 4:00 AM SHE CRYES AND STACHES AT ARE BEDROOM DOOR WHAT SHOULD WE DO TO HELP HER

5
Cats Deserve More
by Tamara on 01/26/2010 02:23pm

I am the proud mama of 2 cats. They are my family, and it angers me when people make derogatory remarks about cats. My cats are as affectionate as dogs. They greet me at the door, sleep near me at night and during the day, follow me from room to room & chair to chair... They are as devoted to me as I am to them. They are not standoffish or uncompanionable at all!

6
by Judi on 01/26/2010 05:40pm

On the food thing, is that cost per pound of cat/dog or of food? Considering the relative size of the average dog and cat, one would expect dogs to be larger and thus eat more. If the price per pound of food is the same, then feeding X number of dogs will cost more than feeding (same) X number of cats.

Collars. Dogs go out in public more (on average) than cats, so are more likely to have the need to wear a collar, period. My personal dogs tend to have pretty basic collars for everyday wear, although I often have 2 per dog so I have one to use while the other is in the wash. Other people tend toward more variety and ornateness in their collars. Dogs may also have different competition collars for various sports they compete in (in most competitions, tags are not allowed on collars). Cats tend to be involved in fewer organized sports than dogs.

Grooming. Since most people don't socialize their cats to car rides and new experiences, going to a groomer is traumatic and tends to be avoided. Also, if one sticks to shorter-haired cats, the cats themselves and simple brushes are usually enough to keep the cats looking good. I have seen a good number of longer-haired cats who can't really cope with their hair and could use a good grooming, though.

Why don't we encourage cat owners to socialize their kittens and take them out and about like we do puppies? I think kitten kindergarten would be about the cutest thing ever! Seems like it would make going to a groomer or a vet less traumatic, if the car ride getting there weren't such a big deal first.

7
by JaneA on 01/26/2010 06:03pm

I think Delores put her finger on one possible reason why cats get less vet care than dogs: people who have cats tend to have more of them. A checkup for one cat costs as much as a checkup for one dog, no matter what the size difference. It's rare to see a person who owns more than one or two dogs, but not at all uncommon for people to care for multiple cats.

For me, this underscores the importance of really thinking before adopting a cat or adding cats, about the practical consequences of that decision. I have three (incredibly loving, devoted, affectionate, and downright dog-like--don't tell them I said that!) cats right now, all of whom get regular vet care and a very high-quality diet. Although I have room in my heart for a dozen cats, I know I couldn't afford to provide proper food and vet care for a dozen (or even four) cats.

So, ultimately, between the resources available issue and the general attitude you describe (cats are fine on their own, blah blah blah), I think you've got your answer on why cats get less care all around.

8
Bad past experiences w/cats
by Cat Purrson on 01/26/2010 08:11pm

I agree with "all of the above." Supply is probably the biggest contributor. Cats are fecund, many people don't spay/neuter, or there is an "oops" litter, much more so than dogs. One usually has to go out and *get* a dog but cats are thrust upon one.

In my experience a huge, HUGE factor of cat dislike is not having a good experience with cats. If your only experience with cats is with ferals, strays, or poorly socialized "porch cats" then you get a bad impression of the whole species. Then you meet someone's friendly, neutered, flea-free indoor pet cats and it's a revelation! I've done that for people - they've met my cats and said, I didn't know cats were this nice, and clean, and quiet, etc.

There is hope. The status of cats has risen since the 1970's when most cats were outside only, didn't get taken to the vet *period*, didn't get neutered *period,* stood practically zero chance of adoption from shelters...we really have come a long way since then, at least on the coasts.

9
by Jacqueline on 01/27/2010 09:10am

Great article, Dr. Patty. I have both dogs and cats and the dogs-to-cat going to the vet ratio is about 8:1, but that's just because the dogs seem to get sick more often. The cats just seem much healthier and dont' get ear infections, or skin stuff, or anything, really... They're just healthier. My dogs, Lord, it's always something ....

10
tired of dissing of cats
by patricia Add on 01/30/2010 06:44am

I think that's a pathetic and prejudice reply about cats,i do prefer cats but i love all animals i have two dogs. At least cats have enough class not to sniff each others rears,and they also do not leave a bad odor if the slightest bit of water gets on their fur. Dogs are smart, but cats aren't any less intelligent if a vet is going be partial to a specific animal then put up a sign on your door or etc, saying no cats allowed they will be shot on site. A true animal lover truly cares for all animals. Also they understand that whether large or small they all have feelings and know whether their liked or not,and open hearts waiting to be loved.

LEAVE COMMENTS

Please login or sign up to leave comments.



Photo of Patty Khuly

Patty Khuly

VMD, MBA

...is a small animal veterinarian in Miami, Florida, where she practices medicine at Sunset Animal Clinic and serves on the board of the South Florida Veterinary Medical Association. She is a graduate of Wellesley College, the University of Pennsylvania School of Veterinary Medicine, and The Wharton School of Business.

As a significant sideline, she writes...a lot. Apart from her daily blogging here at PetMD's FullyVetted, she authors weekly pet health columns for USA Today and The Miami Herald. She also writes a popular monthly column for Veterinary Practice News and serves as regular contributor to Veterinary Economics, The Bark, and the Veterinary News Network.

Dr. Khuly lives in South Miami with her brood of hens, goats, dogs, cats...and humans.

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE
FULLY VETTED IN YOUR INBOX!

 

The opinions expressed in the PetMD Blogs are of the author and the author alone. They do not reflect the opinions of PetMD and they have not been reviewed by PetMD editorial staff for accuracy, balance or objectivity. PetMD Blogs are not a substitute for professional veterinarian advice, diagnosis, or treatment. PetMD does not endorse any specific product, service or treatment.



EMERGENCIES
DISEASES A-Z
TOPIC CENTERS
PET CARE
BREEDOPEDIA
BLOGS
©1999-2010 PetMD, LLC. All Rights Reserved